5 ms·

Is this AGI? I don't think I can score 100% on ARC AGI.

by program_whiz 26d ago

Insanity 26d ago
Depends on which definition they’ll use today.
chris_st 26d ago
You'll find that those goalposts are very movable.
mdp2021 26d ago
[dead]
tiahura 26d ago
Could KITT? Cmdr. Data?
m3kw9 26d ago
agi with a context of 250k-1mill tokens?
deleted 26d ago
[deleted]
inerte 26d ago
It is until ARC-AGI-4. Maybe around 73 we will stop.
adastra22 26d ago
Yes, we’ve had AGI for years now.
- program_whiz 26d ago
  Its interesting because I didn't think it was, but then reading the NVIDIA approach, this kind of loop plus generating a program to explain things. Maybe that is AGI? I don't know, but it seems like an additional layer that maybe is a fundamental shift in capabilities (kind of like reinforcement learning and COT was).
  - adastra22 26d ago
    The capability for a man-made machine machine to solve problems drawn from arbitrary problem domains without domain specific pre-training: Artificial. General. Intelligence. AGI. It is what the term of art means.
daemonologist 26d ago
You could probably score 100% on ARC 3 if you were motivated enough. I find some of the current problems to be kind of like Chess - mechanically simple, and ~solvable, but it's difficult to force myself to think at length about a monotonous and meaningless problem. The machines do have an advantage on the "energy" front; they've become almost psychotically persistent (and don't get tired after too many prompts). Anyway yes I think we've had AGI for a while now, even if the GI doesn't quite match up with what we expect from a human.
edgarvaldes 26d ago
>A 100% score means AI agents can beat every game as efficiently as humans. (0) Yey, AGI is finally solved. (0) https://arcprize.org/arc-agi/3 https://arcprize.org/arc-agi/3
andriy_koval 26d ago
> Is this AGI? I don't think I can score 100% on ARC AGI. 100% is some "RHAE" metric: its performance of median human first time seeing those problem.
oblio 26d ago
What's AGI, at the end of the day? Equivalence to the average human?

Is this AGI? I don't think I can score 100% on ARC AGI.

Insanity 26d ago

Depends on which definition they’ll use today.

chris_st 26d ago

You'll find that those goalposts are very movable.

mdp2021 26d ago

[dead]

tiahura 26d ago

Could KITT? Cmdr. Data?

m3kw9 26d ago

agi with a context of 250k-1mill tokens?

deleted 26d ago

[deleted]

inerte 26d ago

It is until ARC-AGI-4. Maybe around 73 we will stop.

adastra22 26d ago

Yes, we’ve had AGI for years now.

program_whiz 26d ago
Its interesting because I didn't think it was, but then reading the NVIDIA approach, this kind of loop plus generating a program to explain things. Maybe that is AGI? I don't know, but it seems like an additional layer that maybe is a fundamental shift in capabilities (kind of like reinforcement learning and COT was).
- adastra22 26d ago
  The capability for a man-made machine machine to solve problems drawn from arbitrary problem domains without domain specific pre-training: Artificial. General. Intelligence. AGI. It is what the term of art means.

daemonologist 26d ago

You could probably score 100% on ARC 3 if you were motivated enough. I find some of the current problems to be kind of like Chess - mechanically simple, and ~solvable, but it's difficult to force myself to think at length about a monotonous and meaningless problem. The machines do have an advantage on the "energy" front; they've become almost psychotically persistent (and don't get tired after too many prompts). Anyway yes I think we've had AGI for a while now, even if the GI doesn't quite match up with what we expect from a human.

edgarvaldes 26d ago

>A 100% score means AI agents can beat every game as efficiently as humans. (0) Yey, AGI is finally solved. (0) https://arcprize.org/arc-agi/3 https://arcprize.org/arc-agi/3

andriy_koval 26d ago

> Is this AGI? I don't think I can score 100% on ARC AGI. 100% is some "RHAE" metric: its performance of median human first time seeing those problem.

oblio 26d ago

What's AGI, at the end of the day? Equivalence to the average human?