4 ms·

This is much better than the current slop post. Could it be swapped, please @dang?

by wlkr 4mo ago

fragmede 4mo ago
@dang doesn't do anything. email hn@ycombinator.com to get his/other moderators attention (which I did).
walletdrainer 4mo ago
The tweets by Josef Prusa also seem LLM generated, this whole story is slop.
- dolebirchwood 4mo ago
  These banal accusations are so dim and dull.
  - walletdrainer 4mo ago
    Banal accusations? Here's the frequency of the " - " pattern in tweets by "josefprusa" 2020: 8 / 761 tweets = 1.1% 2021: 5 / 533 tweets = 0.9% 2022: 9 / 597 tweets = 1.5% 2023: 21 / 450 tweets = 4.7% 2024: 57 / 725 tweets = 7.9% 2025: 23 / 390 tweets = 5.9% 2026: 15 / 136 tweets = 11.0% Now, go ahead and tell me this guy is not yet another spammer polluting social media with LLM-generated garbage.
N-Krause 4mo ago
The article linked here is a consequence of the actions taken against the repository linked by OP, not a more 'credible source'. The file linked in by OP, is the main argument by Pawel Jarczak why his fork does not violate any copyright laws (may it be written by/with help of AI or not).
- wlkr 4mo ago
  I didn't say it was necessarily more credible, although I understand that was mentioned further up. Personally I found the article (not the tweets) much more useful to understand the context of all this, as someone very out of the loop. Certianly more useful to me than a long list of very specific, in my option largely LLM output, points about a codebase I'm entirely unfamiliar with with claims that seem to need a legal team and court case to be meaningful. Slop is somewhat unfair and I'm happy to be disagreed with.
  - marcosscriven 4mo ago
    Indeed. It’s not clear at all to me that this is a better or even equivalent post to the one I submitted.
sbrocket 4mo ago
It is kooky that you think some conspiracy nonsense about Bambu being a Chinese company and so something from Josef Prusa, is better than a detailed (if AI-written) analysis of all the ways that Bambu's networking plugin is a tightly integrated component of the AGPLv3 Bambu Studio from the creator of the only reimplementation of that plugin that exists/existed who is the direct target of Bambu's recent legal threats.

This is much better than the current slop post. Could it be swapped, please @dang?

by wlkr 4mo ago

This is much better than the current slop post. Could it be swapped, please @dang?

fragmede 4mo ago

@dang doesn't do anything. email hn@ycombinator.com to get his/other moderators attention (which I did).

walletdrainer 4mo ago

The tweets by Josef Prusa also seem LLM generated, this whole story is slop.

dolebirchwood 4mo ago
These banal accusations are so dim and dull.
- walletdrainer 4mo ago
  Banal accusations? Here's the frequency of the " - " pattern in tweets by "josefprusa" 2020: 8 / 761 tweets = 1.1% 2021: 5 / 533 tweets = 0.9% 2022: 9 / 597 tweets = 1.5% 2023: 21 / 450 tweets = 4.7% 2024: 57 / 725 tweets = 7.9% 2025: 23 / 390 tweets = 5.9% 2026: 15 / 136 tweets = 11.0% Now, go ahead and tell me this guy is not yet another spammer polluting social media with LLM-generated garbage.

N-Krause 4mo ago

The article linked here is a consequence of the actions taken against the repository linked by OP, not a more 'credible source'. The file linked in by OP, is the main argument by Pawel Jarczak why his fork does not violate any copyright laws (may it be written by/with help of AI or not).

wlkr 4mo ago
I didn't say it was necessarily more credible, although I understand that was mentioned further up. Personally I found the article (not the tweets) much more useful to understand the context of all this, as someone very out of the loop. Certianly more useful to me than a long list of very specific, in my option largely LLM output, points about a codebase I'm entirely unfamiliar with with claims that seem to need a legal team and court case to be meaningful. Slop is somewhat unfair and I'm happy to be disagreed with.
- marcosscriven 4mo ago
  Indeed. It’s not clear at all to me that this is a better or even equivalent post to the one I submitted.

sbrocket 4mo ago

It is kooky that you think some conspiracy nonsense about Bambu being a Chinese company and so something from Josef Prusa, is better than a detailed (if AI-written) analysis of all the ways that Bambu's networking plugin is a tightly integrated component of the AGPLv3 Bambu Studio from the creator of the only reimplementation of that plugin that exists/existed who is the direct target of Bambu's recent legal threats.