Y
HN Search
Hacker News Search
new
|
comments
|
top
|
jobs
thatsmyfribble
searching Neon…
1.
▲
2.
▲
3.
▲
4.
▲
5.
▲
6.
▲
4 ms
·
1.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
It's definitely a very difficult issue, and the answer is definitely better left to someone with more political experience than myself (having zero), and with more knowledge of the Israeli political structure, but to start with- 1. Isr
2.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
That's where the argument over whether Israel should be a Jewish state or a state of the Jews comes from. Should Israel be a Jewish theocracy, or should it be a secular homeland for the Jewish people as an ethnic group? If you find the
3.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
I don't agree that there is anything fundamentally antisemitic about criticizing Israel or its policies. While I think some antisemitic people hold that viewpoint, there is plenty of valid criticism for the actions of the Israeli gover
4.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
The phrasing of the disgusting line is unclear, I apologize. I'm not calling people claiming that disgusting, I'm commenting on people who are calling the concept of a Jewish state disgusting, as in, I'm commenting on people
5.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
My comment was phrased poorly. I didn't mean to say it was disgusting to call Israel a racist state, I commented on people who are calling Israel's actions disgusting--I apologize if that wasn't a clear distinction in my comm
6.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
I think in a conversation that's this divisive it's critical to be semantically very clear. I don't know that I'm using any sleights of hand, but if you want to agree to very specific definitions on the terms being discu
7.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
Yes. The premise of a state which is 'for' a specific group inherently employs segregation. I say subjugation because I think there is a version of that system that maintains a Jewish ruling majority without subjugating the minori
8.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
No, not a bot either, just don't want my actual account getting downvoted to hell for expressing my honest opinion.
9.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
I don't think it was built with the intention of subjugation, but I think it has been a consequence of its implementation and politics. I do think there is a version of a Jewish state that doesn't behave like this, but its current
10.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
You can get by the Reuters paywall in an incognito window.
11.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
This law doesn't restrict marriages, it restricts citizenship through marriages for Palestinians. I'm not defending that but I am clarifying it.
12.
▲
by
thatsmyfribble
5y ago
First of all, this isn't a ban on Israeli-Palestinian marriage, this is a restriction on the ability to gain citizenship through those marriages. I don't agree with that, but I do think it's important to clarify. Regarding co