21 ms·

Techstars to open up shop in Detroit

145 points by nwest 12y ago

valarauca1 12y ago
As a Detroiter hopefully this will give me a reason to start going downtown. The current problem with the Detroit Metro area is when ever outside money comes in. Most the time the offices open in the northern/western suburbs. I say this because most high paying jobs are in the suburbs. Because that's where the businesses are. The suburbs are doing well. At first I was very excited and hoped they'd open relatively close, but all things consider that wouldn't help the city as much.
- emcrazyone 12y ago
  up voted you and I agree. I grew up in what is referred to as the "Down River" area; the suburbs south of Detroit and I now live ~10-15 miles north of Detroit. After living here some 30+ years I'm ready to pack it up. Until Detroit can get rid of it's crime and the stigma that seems to linger, I have a hard time imagining anyone wanting to spend any time near the city after dark. I own my own company and I have clients in the city; the Comerica building just to name one. If we are on a project that puts any of us down there after 5pm, we'er in pairs. I'm originally from New York; parents moved to Detroit area when I was kid. I remember growing up listening to family constantly being concerned for our safety and when I got married about 10 years ago, I had a hard time convincing my NY relatives that Livonia was safe to visit. (Livonia is North & East of Detroit). My mom worked in Detroit (McNamara building). She would take the bus into the city. If she missed the bus ride home, my dad and I would have to drive down to pick her up. We would always get this nervous feeling coming off I-75 by the old Tiger Stadium. The McNamara building is a federal building so it had high security which I think gave my dad some comfort but still, Detroit's crime has always over shadowed the place for as long as I've been here. We even have stupid comments big celeberties like Ted Nugent who say we're the murder captial not because we shoot more people but because we're better shooters. I digress... I'm hopeful things will turn around but as a father now with kids, I'm always on the lookout to get out still. Including moving my company HQ.
  - mingmecca 12y ago
    Hey! I grew up in the Downriver area as well (Lincoln Park specifically, about which the less said the better). Growing up, I only ever went into Detroit for concerts and the semi-annual "Greektown" pilgrimage. Outside of that, it was blight everywhere, and I thought that is how a big city looked. It wasn't until my college years that I seen a bit more of the world and my perspective changed on urban areas. Overall, I think Techstars moving in will be enormously positive. Cheap rents, stalwart employees (because of the bitter winters), and a "we can only go up from here" attitude is a good mix.
    - emcrazyone 12y ago
      I'm from from Riverview.
- Igglyboo 12y ago
  The only time I ever go downtown is for events at the Renaissance Center and Cobo Hall. There's really no reason to otherwise, unless you like to gamble. Pretty much everywhere outside of the immediate area around Cobo is really bad anyway.
  - valarauca1 12y ago
    The Greektown area is nicer. Fairly good restaurants aimed at younger people, I've frequented that area often without a problem. The "Down Town" area is perfectly fine. I have friends who live down town. Just when you leave that bubble protected by freeways it gets very bad very fast.
    - Igglyboo 12y ago
      Sorry, I was kind of including the Greektown area in that general area. I don't really gamble so I usually don't go their but the food is pretty good. Most of the stops on the people mover seem to be decent neighborhoods as well.
  - borat4prez 12y ago
    The music scene is pretty good down there. Been to some great shows over the past few years.
  - mklim 12y ago
    > There's really no reason to otherwise, unless you like to gamble. That's really not true. There's a ton of fantastic restaurants/coffee places that don't exist in the suburbs (Mudgie's, Slowe's, Great Lakes Coffee, etc), the Detroit Art Institute in Midtown (including famous works like Van Gogh's self portrait), a music scene ranging from the big pop stars at Fox Theater to the up and coming indie bands at the Magic Stick, there's all the sporting events, there's ice skating at Campus Martius during the winter and free music at Grand Circus during the summer, there's the Opera House, there's touring Broadway shows at the Fox, there's smaller but still professional theater at the Hillberry, and there's a few regular tech meetups that take place downtown (Detroit Google Developer's Group, Lambda Lounge, Detroit Craftsman's Guild). There's almost always something going on in the Downtown/Midtown area.
phkahler 12y ago
While this is great news, I think YC-Detroit would have been even better ;-) There is a lot of talent here. As evidence, here's the First Robotics Competition team map: https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=zIJNq656OeBY.ke6fB8FLJTDI&ie=UTF&msa=0 https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=zIJNq656OeBY.ke6fB8... Our teams also have a long history of winning ;-)
- yesimahuman 12y ago
  While YC is a wonderful program, I think it'd be nice to give some props and support to programs like TechStars that are actively expanding and supporting startup cities outside of the valley.
  - phkahler 12y ago
    I completely agree. It's just that YC kinda has a reputation as being #1 at least for the kinds of startups they do. Either way, Detroit (or the Detroit area) has been overlooked IMHO and this is still a great thing to see.
    - yesimahuman 12y ago
      Yep, I would love to see YC expand beyond the valley (drawing a bit on their east-coast past), though I can't blame them for focusing there.
monsterix 12y ago
I wish there was something like this here in DC. Very little startup scene. All I get to see are those sweettalk recruitment shops and those three lettered agencies that I couldn't imagine working for. Good news for you Detroit!
- deleted 12y ago
  [deleted]
- Bahamut 12y ago
  I don't recall that being the case - there are plenty of small companies in the area. The one problem all of them face though is funding is difficult to obtain there, but I have found that higher quality companies emerge as a result.
- troycroz 12y ago
  acceleprise, 1776, paul singh, steve case, 5-10 coworking spaces... DC startup scene is hardly dead.
- ryanSrich 12y ago
  I had the complete opposite experience in DC. There are a TON of startups in DC. Far more than where I live now (Portland OR). You should checkout über offices. They have 5-10 startups working out of all three locations (most of with funding). On top of the co-working/startup spaces you have other accelerators and funding opportunities like 1776 and Acceleprise. The DC startup scene is definitely healthy.
- jasondc 12y ago
  I agree, I've lived in DC my whole life and always told myself the startup scene was great there. Then I moved to NYC, and now Palo Alto. The startup scene in DC is horrible compared to similar sized cities (by contrast Portland has Nike, Intel, New Relic, Puppet Labs, etc.), and DC is dominated by the federal government. Why work at a startup in DC when you can make $150k+ as a gov't contractor in DC.
borat4prez 12y ago
How do I apply my Detroit area startup? The application on the website is only for Austin.
- mooreds 12y ago
  They have rolling applications, so each city has a different application period. Also, they probably won't take applications until the official announcement.
azilnik 12y ago
Does anyone else feel like Detroit is going to be an attractive place for young tech folks to start their businesses in the next 10 years? Are there any Detroit-centric REITs out there?
johnvschmitt 12y ago
Great news & I have more hope for the community. However, many people outside of the startup scene have misconceptions, as they see survivor bias/success bias in the reporting. One item in the report feeds this misconception: "The average company got $1.9 million in funding." The median raised would be far more revealing of the actual experience that a startup faces than the average.
- cj 12y ago
  Techstars is incredibly transparent with their stats. Full funding data available here: http://www.techstars.com/companies/stats/ http://www.techstars.com/companies/stats/ I just pulled some numbers quickly... In the last 3 Techstars NYC batches (not including the most recent), there were 37 companies with median funding of just over $1.6 million. 28 are still active, 6 have been acquired and 3 have failed.
  - johnvschmitt 12y ago
    Thanks. That is indeed an incredible level of transparency. I didn't see a CSV download but just scanning, it looks like it's more like a $200k median, with 1.6M average. Medians just make far more sense in letting someone outside the system know what to expect. Just like, "The average actress in Hollywood makes $250k, when in fact the median is $30k and a few make $100M).
    - cj 12y ago
      They don't have a CSV export, but here's a quick Javascript script that pulls the fundings and calculates the median and average. Total companies: 486 Median funding: $450,000 Average funding: $2,039,918 Total funding: $991,400,000 var fundings = $('.batch .parent .right').map(function(){ return +this.innerHTML.replace(/(\$|,| )/g, '') || 0; }).toArray(); fundings = fundings.sort(function(a, b) { return a - b; }); var totalFunding = fundings.reduce(function(a, b) { return a + b; }); console.log('Total companies: ', fundings.length); console.log('Median funding: ', fundings[Math.round(fundings.length / 2)]); console.log('Average funding: ', Math.round(totalFunding / fundings.length));
ThomPete 12y ago
I have said it before and I will say it again. Detroit is the perfect place to build the robotics industry and they should call it Uncanny Vally.
- dominotw 12y ago
  >Detroit is the perfect place to build the robotics industry Why?
  - ThomPete 12y ago
    Access to a technical population that are still there from the auto industry. Cheap land to build large testing facilities. Infrastructure that is only recently started to erode to test out various robots on. Cheap cost of living in an otherwise capital intensive industry.
  - valarauca1 12y ago
    Mechanical and Technical engineering base of the city already exists. The automotive industry has already created a host of general consulting engineering companies specializing in everything from hydraulics to electronics to fluid flow is insane. One area of the city is literally known as "automation alley" due to the huge number of PLC controlled robots it produced in the 80's and 90's. The ideas of line automation were invented in Detroit. Also the exposure the metro-area children get to this technology is unpresendented. While HN doesn't seem to be "big" on First/FRC high school robotics competition. Nearly every school in the suburbs has a team that builds at least 1 50k+ robot per year to compete locally. There are multiple programs and competitions FIRST isn't the only. I bring this up because Michigan teams don't exactly compete but dominate was a better word before the region limiting system was put in place. Finally the education system is also in place. Lawerence/Kettering university were founded by Ford and GM as trade schools to crank out engineers for their companies, now they're private universes. But the it demonstrates just how many engineer degrees come from the state let alone the metro area.
    - IndianAstronaut 12y ago
marksc 12y ago
This is great news! Though, I'm surprised they aren't coming to Ann Arbor- the real startup hub of Michigan.
- rezistik 12y ago
  I live in Ann Arbor, and I've worked at a start up in Detroit, in what world is Ann Arbor the start up hub? Detroit has far more start ups and venture capital firms...mostly owned/invested in by Quicken but the point stands.
  - vnchr 12y ago
    It might be an awareness issue. A2 has had a startup scene longer than Detroit. I was in QL's Bizdom accelerator in 2008-09, and there was no VC or startup scene to speak of. UMich has been spinning out tech startups regularly for a decade. The two ecosystems exist siloed from each other, but I think Detroit is a better choice since A2 startups can flock there and there is a faster growing community from what I can tell.
  - jasallen 12y ago
    If you worked at a start up in Detroit, you were defacto a part of the Gilbert Mafia. I don't say that disparagingly, Dan Gilbert crew have done great things for the city, but its a one shop town. A2 lacks a Dan Gilbert to make all the things happen, but it has a much more vibrant, Bay-like share-and-share alike, encouraging, open start-up culture. Plug for A2-NewTech, a start-up meetup I'm a huge fan of (I'm not affiliated, just a fan)
    - rezistik 12y ago
      I'll have to check out A2-NewTech. It's awesome to know I've been wrong about my (new) home town.
  - marksc 12y ago
    The fastest growing tech startup in the Midwest in 2013 and 2014 was and is in A2 (Duo Security). We have multiple Google Ventures, True Ventures, Resonant Venture, etc. startups. We have the Tech Brewery, A2 New Tech, SPARK, Tech Arb, etc. Barracuda Networks was started here. Google's Michigan office is here. One of the top 5 public universities in the world is all around us. I can't imagine why anyone on HN would drive from Ann Arbor to Detroit for work when there are much better and higher paying prospects right here in A2.
iwantagrinder 12y ago
Gilbert's plan is working.
ryanmarsh 12y ago
As a Houstonion this gives me pause. Houston is a massive economic center by nearly every measure. It is also home to the most diverse county and university in the US. There are large successful technology companies here. Yet, Detroit and Dallas (arch enemy of Houston) are getting TechStars before us. Part of the reason we don't attract accelerators like TechStars is the lack of a healthy startup ecosystem. I am NOT saying that the well intentioned community organizers aren't working hard. It's just that most of the VC here goes to Oil & Gas projects. If your tech isn't energy related it won't hit the radar. The technology startup successes I've seen in my 30 or so years here were built inspite of a (nonexistent) local startup ecosystem. Lastly, 9 out of 10 great people I've worked with here have left to go places with more tech opportunity. The talent is voting with its feet. Frankly, I'm done too. I'm on the first airplane out of here once I get my feet under me. I'm sad that it has to be this way. Maybe if I make it rich I'll come back and invest. edit: spelling
- jusben1369 12y ago
  I guess the question is what makes for a good techhub/incubator. It seems to me embracing of a counter culture lifestyle is the key early differentiator. Certainly the Bay Area once had that. Austin. Seattle. Even Durham NC where I'm based now and is having a (relative) boom rose out of abandoned tobacco warehouses that could afford to support all types of people. I haven't been there in 8 years but I hear Detroit has that going for it now too. Houston with it's established booming energy sector probably doesn't draw in the right type of culture. (Although I have no response for Dallas vs Houston so you've got me there) Sure you need good universities and cheap accommodation etc but it strikes me there has to be something unique and alternative to draw in the igniters of a new hub.
  - bluedino 12y ago
    One thing that San Francisco has that somewhere like Detroit doesn't, is the affluent residents with the ability to sustain a service like Uber or startups such as food delivery. Those kind of services are viable to create a startup focused on in SF but not in Detroit.
bruceb 12y ago
There is already at least one accelerator in Detroit. http://bizdom.com/ http://bizdom.com/ It is partially funded by the Dan Gilbert, founder of Quicken Loans. He also owns the Cleveland Cavilers and partial funds same thing in Cleveland. Detroit is cheap compared to SF but actually downtown is filling up, rents are not as cheap as you might think.
- rezistik 12y ago
  He's also invested in Detroit Venture Partners
alexalex 12y ago
If true and successful, this would be huge for Detroit. I once looked into the suitability of Detroit for a start-up. It seemed that professional services were generally not as interested in working with young companies as in the bay area. The availability of deferred legal, accounting, or other services was non-existent. Being in the bay area, my company has benefited greatly from having deferred legal work. I also worried about finding good advisers. With Techstars there, it would definitely solve these problems for their awardees. While there aren't a wealth of affluent, urban customers in the city, there would be great opportunities for consumer or educational startups that address problems for the base of the pyramid. Whole Foods opened a store in Detroit, and talked more about it in their last quarterly conference call than any other topic. Ostensibly, figuring out how to be successful in markets like Detroit is a huge opportunity for growth for them. Finally, the city of Detroit has neighborhoods that are young and affluent. Inventory is very limited, and rents in the highest profile areas are as high as most big cities -- think Lake Merritt in Oakland. I really hope TechStars is successful there. Detroit is a place dear in my heart and not as scary as many think. I lived in SF's SOMA 10-ish years ago, and can say that I had way crazier stories and more dangerous moments than my mom, who has been working in Detroit Public Schools since her retirement.
- calbear81 12y ago
  Although I'm glad Whole Foods is in Midtown, it's not catered towards the "base of the pyramid". Every time I've been in there, the customers are primarily the hip newcomers who have moved to Midtown or folks from Oakland county coming in to catch an exhibit at the DIA or symphony. I would love to see development happen in the areas that need it more and not just in the rapidly gentrifying downtown core.
youssifa 12y ago
If you're a startup founder accepted into Detroit Tech Stars (or even a YC) who lives in a foreign country, there should be a policy in place to give you an accelerated visa to work / live in the US provided you base your startup out of Detroit. Could be a good policy experiment on urban renewal.
drawkbox 12y ago
Happy for Detroit, I think there is a responsibility of tech leaders to get this throughout our nation not concentrate it, no single point of failure, plus more input from different areas means better products + systems which are more robust. However, when is someone going to setup in Phoenix (Chandler, Scottsdale, Tempe)? Huge market, short flight to CA, always overlooked. Gangplank (web/app/product), Game Co-lab (games) co-working locations + ASU are doing a good job for startups but it would be awesome for more investment here, fairly untapped and a blue ocean in the desert where we have to stay indoors working most of the time anyways.
chandrew 12y ago
Hello from the Techstars office, Austin.

145 points by nwest 12y ago

As a Detroiter hopefully this will give me a reason to start going downtown. The current problem with the Detroit Metro area is when ever outside money comes in. Most the time the offices open in the northern/western suburbs. I say this because most high paying jobs are in the suburbs. Because that's where the businesses are. The suburbs are doing well. At first I was very excited and hoped they'd open relatively close, but all things consider that wouldn't help the city as much.

emcrazyone 12y ago
up voted you and I agree. I grew up in what is referred to as the "Down River" area; the suburbs south of Detroit and I now live ~10-15 miles north of Detroit. After living here some 30+ years I'm ready to pack it up. Until Detroit can get rid of it's crime and the stigma that seems to linger, I have a hard time imagining anyone wanting to spend any time near the city after dark. I own my own company and I have clients in the city; the Comerica building just to name one. If we are on a project that puts any of us down there after 5pm, we'er in pairs. I'm originally from New York; parents moved to Detroit area when I was kid. I remember growing up listening to family constantly being concerned for our safety and when I got married about 10 years ago, I had a hard time convincing my NY relatives that Livonia was safe to visit. (Livonia is North & East of Detroit). My mom worked in Detroit (McNamara building). She would take the bus into the city. If she missed the bus ride home, my dad and I would have to drive down to pick her up. We would always get this nervous feeling coming off I-75 by the old Tiger Stadium. The McNamara building is a federal building so it had high security which I think gave my dad some comfort but still, Detroit's crime has always over shadowed the place for as long as I've been here. We even have stupid comments big celeberties like Ted Nugent who say we're the murder captial not because we shoot more people but because we're better shooters. I digress... I'm hopeful things will turn around but as a father now with kids, I'm always on the lookout to get out still. Including moving my company HQ.
- mingmecca 12y ago
  Hey! I grew up in the Downriver area as well (Lincoln Park specifically, about which the less said the better). Growing up, I only ever went into Detroit for concerts and the semi-annual "Greektown" pilgrimage. Outside of that, it was blight everywhere, and I thought that is how a big city looked. It wasn't until my college years that I seen a bit more of the world and my perspective changed on urban areas. Overall, I think Techstars moving in will be enormously positive. Cheap rents, stalwart employees (because of the bitter winters), and a "we can only go up from here" attitude is a good mix.
  - emcrazyone 12y ago
    I'm from from Riverview.
Igglyboo 12y ago
The only time I ever go downtown is for events at the Renaissance Center and Cobo Hall. There's really no reason to otherwise, unless you like to gamble. Pretty much everywhere outside of the immediate area around Cobo is really bad anyway.
- valarauca1 12y ago
  The Greektown area is nicer. Fairly good restaurants aimed at younger people, I've frequented that area often without a problem. The "Down Town" area is perfectly fine. I have friends who live down town. Just when you leave that bubble protected by freeways it gets very bad very fast.
  - Igglyboo 12y ago
    Sorry, I was kind of including the Greektown area in that general area. I don't really gamble so I usually don't go their but the food is pretty good. Most of the stops on the people mover seem to be decent neighborhoods as well.
- borat4prez 12y ago
  The music scene is pretty good down there. Been to some great shows over the past few years.
- mklim 12y ago
  > There's really no reason to otherwise, unless you like to gamble. That's really not true. There's a ton of fantastic restaurants/coffee places that don't exist in the suburbs (Mudgie's, Slowe's, Great Lakes Coffee, etc), the Detroit Art Institute in Midtown (including famous works like Van Gogh's self portrait), a music scene ranging from the big pop stars at Fox Theater to the up and coming indie bands at the Magic Stick, there's all the sporting events, there's ice skating at Campus Martius during the winter and free music at Grand Circus during the summer, there's the Opera House, there's touring Broadway shows at the Fox, there's smaller but still professional theater at the Hillberry, and there's a few regular tech meetups that take place downtown (Detroit Google Developer's Group, Lambda Lounge, Detroit Craftsman's Guild). There's almost always something going on in the Downtown/Midtown area.

phkahler 12y ago

While this is great news, I think YC-Detroit would have been even better ;-) There is a lot of talent here. As evidence, here's the First Robotics Competition team map: https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=zIJNq656OeBY.ke6fB8FLJTDI&ie=UTF&msa=0 https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=zIJNq656OeBY.ke6fB8... Our teams also have a long history of winning ;-)

yesimahuman 12y ago
While YC is a wonderful program, I think it'd be nice to give some props and support to programs like TechStars that are actively expanding and supporting startup cities outside of the valley.
- phkahler 12y ago
  I completely agree. It's just that YC kinda has a reputation as being #1 at least for the kinds of startups they do. Either way, Detroit (or the Detroit area) has been overlooked IMHO and this is still a great thing to see.
  - yesimahuman 12y ago
    Yep, I would love to see YC expand beyond the valley (drawing a bit on their east-coast past), though I can't blame them for focusing there.

monsterix 12y ago

I wish there was something like this here in DC. Very little startup scene. All I get to see are those sweettalk recruitment shops and those three lettered agencies that I couldn't imagine working for. Good news for you Detroit!

deleted 12y ago
[deleted]
Bahamut 12y ago
I don't recall that being the case - there are plenty of small companies in the area. The one problem all of them face though is funding is difficult to obtain there, but I have found that higher quality companies emerge as a result.
troycroz 12y ago
acceleprise, 1776, paul singh, steve case, 5-10 coworking spaces... DC startup scene is hardly dead.
ryanSrich 12y ago
I had the complete opposite experience in DC. There are a TON of startups in DC. Far more than where I live now (Portland OR). You should checkout über offices. They have 5-10 startups working out of all three locations (most of with funding). On top of the co-working/startup spaces you have other accelerators and funding opportunities like 1776 and Acceleprise. The DC startup scene is definitely healthy.
jasondc 12y ago
I agree, I've lived in DC my whole life and always told myself the startup scene was great there. Then I moved to NYC, and now Palo Alto. The startup scene in DC is horrible compared to similar sized cities (by contrast Portland has Nike, Intel, New Relic, Puppet Labs, etc.), and DC is dominated by the federal government. Why work at a startup in DC when you can make $150k+ as a gov't contractor in DC.

borat4prez 12y ago

How do I apply my Detroit area startup? The application on the website is only for Austin.

mooreds 12y ago
They have rolling applications, so each city has a different application period. Also, they probably won't take applications until the official announcement.

azilnik 12y ago

Does anyone else feel like Detroit is going to be an attractive place for young tech folks to start their businesses in the next 10 years? Are there any Detroit-centric REITs out there?

johnvschmitt 12y ago

Great news & I have more hope for the community. However, many people outside of the startup scene have misconceptions, as they see survivor bias/success bias in the reporting. One item in the report feeds this misconception: "The average company got $1.9 million in funding." The median raised would be far more revealing of the actual experience that a startup faces than the average.

cj 12y ago
Techstars is incredibly transparent with their stats. Full funding data available here: http://www.techstars.com/companies/stats/ http://www.techstars.com/companies/stats/ I just pulled some numbers quickly... In the last 3 Techstars NYC batches (not including the most recent), there were 37 companies with median funding of just over $1.6 million. 28 are still active, 6 have been acquired and 3 have failed.
- johnvschmitt 12y ago
  Thanks. That is indeed an incredible level of transparency. I didn't see a CSV download but just scanning, it looks like it's more like a $200k median, with 1.6M average. Medians just make far more sense in letting someone outside the system know what to expect. Just like, "The average actress in Hollywood makes $250k, when in fact the median is $30k and a few make $100M).
  - cj 12y ago
    They don't have a CSV export, but here's a quick Javascript script that pulls the fundings and calculates the median and average. Total companies: 486 Median funding: $450,000 Average funding: $2,039,918 Total funding: $991,400,000 var fundings = $('.batch .parent .right').map(function(){ return +this.innerHTML.replace(/(\$|,| )/g, '') || 0; }).toArray(); fundings = fundings.sort(function(a, b) { return a - b; }); var totalFunding = fundings.reduce(function(a, b) { return a + b; }); console.log('Total companies: ', fundings.length); console.log('Median funding: ', fundings[Math.round(fundings.length / 2)]); console.log('Average funding: ', Math.round(totalFunding / fundings.length));

ThomPete 12y ago

I have said it before and I will say it again. Detroit is the perfect place to build the robotics industry and they should call it Uncanny Vally.

dominotw 12y ago
>Detroit is the perfect place to build the robotics industry Why?
- ThomPete 12y ago
  Access to a technical population that are still there from the auto industry. Cheap land to build large testing facilities. Infrastructure that is only recently started to erode to test out various robots on. Cheap cost of living in an otherwise capital intensive industry.
- valarauca1 12y ago
  Mechanical and Technical engineering base of the city already exists. The automotive industry has already created a host of general consulting engineering companies specializing in everything from hydraulics to electronics to fluid flow is insane. One area of the city is literally known as "automation alley" due to the huge number of PLC controlled robots it produced in the 80's and 90's. The ideas of line automation were invented in Detroit. Also the exposure the metro-area children get to this technology is unpresendented. While HN doesn't seem to be "big" on First/FRC high school robotics competition. Nearly every school in the suburbs has a team that builds at least 1 50k+ robot per year to compete locally. There are multiple programs and competitions FIRST isn't the only. I bring this up because Michigan teams don't exactly compete but dominate was a better word before the region limiting system was put in place. Finally the education system is also in place. Lawerence/Kettering university were founded by Ford and GM as trade schools to crank out engineers for their companies, now they're private universes. But the it demonstrates just how many engineer degrees come from the state let alone the metro area.
  - IndianAstronaut 12y ago

marksc 12y ago

This is great news! Though, I'm surprised they aren't coming to Ann Arbor- the real startup hub of Michigan.

rezistik 12y ago
I live in Ann Arbor, and I've worked at a start up in Detroit, in what world is Ann Arbor the start up hub? Detroit has far more start ups and venture capital firms...mostly owned/invested in by Quicken but the point stands.
- vnchr 12y ago
  It might be an awareness issue. A2 has had a startup scene longer than Detroit. I was in QL's Bizdom accelerator in 2008-09, and there was no VC or startup scene to speak of. UMich has been spinning out tech startups regularly for a decade. The two ecosystems exist siloed from each other, but I think Detroit is a better choice since A2 startups can flock there and there is a faster growing community from what I can tell.
- jasallen 12y ago
  If you worked at a start up in Detroit, you were defacto a part of the Gilbert Mafia. I don't say that disparagingly, Dan Gilbert crew have done great things for the city, but its a one shop town. A2 lacks a Dan Gilbert to make all the things happen, but it has a much more vibrant, Bay-like share-and-share alike, encouraging, open start-up culture. Plug for A2-NewTech, a start-up meetup I'm a huge fan of (I'm not affiliated, just a fan)
  - rezistik 12y ago
    I'll have to check out A2-NewTech. It's awesome to know I've been wrong about my (new) home town.
- marksc 12y ago
  The fastest growing tech startup in the Midwest in 2013 and 2014 was and is in A2 (Duo Security). We have multiple Google Ventures, True Ventures, Resonant Venture, etc. startups. We have the Tech Brewery, A2 New Tech, SPARK, Tech Arb, etc. Barracuda Networks was started here. Google's Michigan office is here. One of the top 5 public universities in the world is all around us. I can't imagine why anyone on HN would drive from Ann Arbor to Detroit for work when there are much better and higher paying prospects right here in A2.

iwantagrinder 12y ago

Gilbert's plan is working.

ryanmarsh 12y ago

As a Houstonion this gives me pause. Houston is a massive economic center by nearly every measure. It is also home to the most diverse county and university in the US. There are large successful technology companies here. Yet, Detroit and Dallas (arch enemy of Houston) are getting TechStars before us. Part of the reason we don't attract accelerators like TechStars is the lack of a healthy startup ecosystem. I am NOT saying that the well intentioned community organizers aren't working hard. It's just that most of the VC here goes to Oil & Gas projects. If your tech isn't energy related it won't hit the radar. The technology startup successes I've seen in my 30 or so years here were built inspite of a (nonexistent) local startup ecosystem. Lastly, 9 out of 10 great people I've worked with here have left to go places with more tech opportunity. The talent is voting with its feet. Frankly, I'm done too. I'm on the first airplane out of here once I get my feet under me. I'm sad that it has to be this way. Maybe if I make it rich I'll come back and invest. edit: spelling

jusben1369 12y ago
I guess the question is what makes for a good techhub/incubator. It seems to me embracing of a counter culture lifestyle is the key early differentiator. Certainly the Bay Area once had that. Austin. Seattle. Even Durham NC where I'm based now and is having a (relative) boom rose out of abandoned tobacco warehouses that could afford to support all types of people. I haven't been there in 8 years but I hear Detroit has that going for it now too. Houston with it's established booming energy sector probably doesn't draw in the right type of culture. (Although I have no response for Dallas vs Houston so you've got me there) Sure you need good universities and cheap accommodation etc but it strikes me there has to be something unique and alternative to draw in the igniters of a new hub.
- bluedino 12y ago
  One thing that San Francisco has that somewhere like Detroit doesn't, is the affluent residents with the ability to sustain a service like Uber or startups such as food delivery. Those kind of services are viable to create a startup focused on in SF but not in Detroit.

bruceb 12y ago

There is already at least one accelerator in Detroit. http://bizdom.com/ http://bizdom.com/ It is partially funded by the Dan Gilbert, founder of Quicken Loans. He also owns the Cleveland Cavilers and partial funds same thing in Cleveland. Detroit is cheap compared to SF but actually downtown is filling up, rents are not as cheap as you might think.

rezistik 12y ago
He's also invested in Detroit Venture Partners

alexalex 12y ago

If true and successful, this would be huge for Detroit. I once looked into the suitability of Detroit for a start-up. It seemed that professional services were generally not as interested in working with young companies as in the bay area. The availability of deferred legal, accounting, or other services was non-existent. Being in the bay area, my company has benefited greatly from having deferred legal work. I also worried about finding good advisers. With Techstars there, it would definitely solve these problems for their awardees. While there aren't a wealth of affluent, urban customers in the city, there would be great opportunities for consumer or educational startups that address problems for the base of the pyramid. Whole Foods opened a store in Detroit, and talked more about it in their last quarterly conference call than any other topic. Ostensibly, figuring out how to be successful in markets like Detroit is a huge opportunity for growth for them. Finally, the city of Detroit has neighborhoods that are young and affluent. Inventory is very limited, and rents in the highest profile areas are as high as most big cities -- think Lake Merritt in Oakland. I really hope TechStars is successful there. Detroit is a place dear in my heart and not as scary as many think. I lived in SF's SOMA 10-ish years ago, and can say that I had way crazier stories and more dangerous moments than my mom, who has been working in Detroit Public Schools since her retirement.

calbear81 12y ago
Although I'm glad Whole Foods is in Midtown, it's not catered towards the "base of the pyramid". Every time I've been in there, the customers are primarily the hip newcomers who have moved to Midtown or folks from Oakland county coming in to catch an exhibit at the DIA or symphony. I would love to see development happen in the areas that need it more and not just in the rapidly gentrifying downtown core.

youssifa 12y ago

If you're a startup founder accepted into Detroit Tech Stars (or even a YC) who lives in a foreign country, there should be a policy in place to give you an accelerated visa to work / live in the US provided you base your startup out of Detroit. Could be a good policy experiment on urban renewal.

drawkbox 12y ago

Happy for Detroit, I think there is a responsibility of tech leaders to get this throughout our nation not concentrate it, no single point of failure, plus more input from different areas means better products + systems which are more robust. However, when is someone going to setup in Phoenix (Chandler, Scottsdale, Tempe)? Huge market, short flight to CA, always overlooked. Gangplank (web/app/product), Game Co-lab (games) co-working locations + ASU are doing a good job for startups but it would be awesome for more investment here, fairly untapped and a blue ocean in the desert where we have to stay indoors working most of the time anyways.

chandrew 12y ago

Hello from the Techstars office, Austin.