5 ms·
> fail closed I understand fail closed to mean, be secure when in failure. And fail open to be continue to operate during a failure. A door that fails closed
by mywittyname 15d ago
> fail closed
I understand fail closed to mean, be secure when in failure. And fail open to be continue to operate during a failure. A door that fails closed would not let anyone in; one that fails open lets everyone in.
But I can see how these are not the mutually exclusive definition the labels imply, especially if you apply the concept to entities that aren't doors or otherwise have explicit open/closed states. It's probably best to just be specific in those cases.
Similarly, open loop vs closed loop seems to trip people up enough that I no longer use it. But the confusion is understandable since "closed loop" being "has a feedback loop" sounds backwards. Which, is the same way it's being used in your fuse example; a "closed" fuse closes the circuit making it live. But it's still backwards from the colloquial usage, even if it's correct in that context.
- bryanlarsen 14d agoIs there colloquial usage? It's common among computer programmers which is where Claude picked it up, but it's still an engineering term there. It's comparable to "literally", which has picked up two opposite meanings, one of which appears to be obviously wrong. But because of the opposite meanings, using it the "correct" way is still wrong -- the only way to win is to not play, to stop using the terms "literally" and "fail-closed".