6 ms·
The challenge is that more and more people are producing project like this - 1,000s of commits and > 200k lines of code - and saying it was carefully created us
by dirkc 2mo ago
The challenge is that more and more people are producing project like this - 1,000s of commits and > 200k lines of code - and saying it was carefully created using agent based workflows and not vibe coded.
- HPsquared 2mo agoIn that case they need to document the process and workflow, and demonstrate the care that was taken.
- jarym 2mo agoQuite amusing we have decades of human written code much of it sub standard and yet no one demanded proof till now of Open Source projects having to ‘demonstrate’ anything. If ya don’t wanna use it, don’t. Simple.
- jgilias 2mo agoI get what you’re saying and agree with the last sentence. Just wanted to touch on the “why” part. In the world of exclusively human written software the existence of the artefact itself (code, documentation) served as the proof that there’s someone with half a brain behind it. Now that’s not the case anymore. The conclusion stays though - it’s OSS, authors/maintainers have no obligation to anyone to do anything. Like it, use it, don’t like it, don’t use it. As for me, I’ve found that the community and activity proxies are still good.
- dirkc 2mo ago> As for me, I’ve found that the community and activity proxies are still good. Definitely still something to look into. A project I'm checking in on from time to time is https://github.com/emdash-cms/emdash/ https://github.com/emdash-cms/emdash/. It will be interesting to see how the project activity is unfolds? Are people using it in production. How many errors do they find. What do those fixes entail. What happens with the docs over time. Etc. I haven't had a change to look in depth, but based on a quick glance I'd say that the activity on the project seems like the tempo you'd expect of a similar open source project.
- HPsquared 2mo agoMaybe the principal maintainer can be trusted, but pull requests could do with some of that evidence.
- mvanbaak 2mo agospec-driven development is pretty good at this
- dmitrygr 2mo ago> The challenge is that Why is that a challenge? As long as they are open about this, all is OK.