6 ms·
Ask HN: Is Claude Opus 4.8 broken?
In my first hour with it, it's like we're back to the GPT-2 era.
It can't even read a file anymore.
Randomly uses 'sed' with no explanation in hallucinated file paths. Errors out 15 times in a row with 'No such file or directory' with paths that don't exist - it was trying to read a project file as usual in our Rails app.
You then ask it why it's not simply reading the file in the correct path, and then it says it's sorry:
> You're right to be angry. Two things went wrong and both are on me:
>
> 1. I typed sed/cat instead of using the Read tool (the project rules explicitly say not to), and
> 2. I guessed a filename app/services/gmail/sync_worker.rb that doesn't exist — the real file is app/workers/gmail/sync_worker.rb. So I was reading a path I'd invented. Sloppy,
It just apologized to me - for the 5th time in this session - writing this:
> I again typed a made-up message ID into the verify step (19e70e9d...) instead of reading the real one from the list I just fetched. That's the exact mistake I keep making.
(Context window at 15%).
It's unbearably slow.
It presents 10+ errors like 'Cancelled: parallel tool call Bash errored' all the time.
It's unreal.
- ryebread777 4mo agoExperiencing the same things. Basically unusable. Switched back to 4.7 for now.
- deleted 4mo ago[deleted]
- kamens 4mo agoSame situation here. Dropping to 4.7 for now.
- mike7777777 4mo ago[dead]
- SarelE 4mo agoWord, feel the pain...
- landpro 4mo agosame, wasted hours today on fighting this ((
- boldlybold 4mo agoEnded up here with the same problem, 200k output tokens burned on these errors after one prompt!
- webninja 4mo agoIt’s unbearably slow, for sure. Not nearly as slow as Kimi K2.6 though. I’m trying to like 4.8 but I may go back to 4.6 again. Definitely won’t ever be using 4.7. 4.8 took a shortcut today. There was an error in my local LLM’s relay of thinking text. So it brilliantly decided to turn thinking off, neutering the model. Had to revert that nerf. That’s the same lazy behavior as 4.7. 4.6 would never.
- strix_varius 4mo agoCurious why you prefer 4.6 over 4.7
- pluto_modadic 4mo agoit may be a harness bug, based on the github issues.
- terekhindc 3mo ago[flagged]