8 ms·

I hacked together something similar to the concept they describe a few months ago (https://github.com/btucker/agentgit https://github.com/btucker/agentgit) and

by btucker 7mo ago

I hacked together something similar to the concept they describe a few months ago (https://github.com/btucker/agentgit https://github.com/btucker/agentgit) and then ended up not actually finding it that useful and abandoning it.

redhale 7mo ago
I feel like the value would be in analyzing those rich traces with another agent to extract (failure) patterns and learnings, as part of a flywheel setup. As a human I would rarely if ever want to look at this -- I don't even have time to look at the final code itself!
- btucker 7mo ago
  Completely agree. But I wonder how much of that is just accomplished with well placed code comments that explain the why for future agent interactions to prevent them from misunderstanding. I have something like this in my AGENTS.md.
- stitched2gethr 7mo ago
  Try running `/insights` with Claude Code.
  - redhale 7mo ago
    There is no such command, according to the docs [0]. /s I continue to find it painfully ironic that the Claude Code team is unable to leverage their deep expertise and unlimited token budget to keep the docs even close to up-to-date automatically. Either that or they have decided accurate docs aren't important. [0] https://code.claude.com/docs/en/interactive-mode#built-in-commands https://code.claude.com/docs/en/interactive-mode#built-in-co...
- cheema33 7mo ago
  > value would be in analyzing those rich traces with another agent to extract (failure) patterns and learnings Claude Code supports hooks. This allows me to run an agent skill at the end of every agent execution to automatically determine if there were any lessons worth learning from the last session. If there were. new agent skills are automatically created or existing ones automatically updated as apporpriate.
  - redhale 7mo ago
    Yes, I've done the same. But the issue is that the agent tends to learn too many lessons, or to overfit those lessons to that single session. I think the benefit of a tool like this is that you can give that agent a wider view when formulating recommendations.

by btucker 7mo ago

redhale 7mo ago

I feel like the value would be in analyzing those rich traces with another agent to extract (failure) patterns and learnings, as part of a flywheel setup. As a human I would rarely if ever want to look at this -- I don't even have time to look at the final code itself!

btucker 7mo ago
Completely agree. But I wonder how much of that is just accomplished with well placed code comments that explain the why for future agent interactions to prevent them from misunderstanding. I have something like this in my AGENTS.md.
stitched2gethr 7mo ago
Try running `/insights` with Claude Code.
- redhale 7mo ago
  There is no such command, according to the docs [0]. /s I continue to find it painfully ironic that the Claude Code team is unable to leverage their deep expertise and unlimited token budget to keep the docs even close to up-to-date automatically. Either that or they have decided accurate docs aren't important. [0] https://code.claude.com/docs/en/interactive-mode#built-in-commands https://code.claude.com/docs/en/interactive-mode#built-in-co...
cheema33 7mo ago
> value would be in analyzing those rich traces with another agent to extract (failure) patterns and learnings Claude Code supports hooks. This allows me to run an agent skill at the end of every agent execution to automatically determine if there were any lessons worth learning from the last session. If there were. new agent skills are automatically created or existing ones automatically updated as apporpriate.
- redhale 7mo ago
  Yes, I've done the same. But the issue is that the agent tends to learn too many lessons, or to overfit those lessons to that single session. I think the benefit of a tool like this is that you can give that agent a wider view when formulating recommendations.