5 ms·

I guess this makes sense Github announced they are gonna bring stacked PRs this year so I think that kinda makes Graphite obsolute.

joshgachnang 9mo ago
Woahhhhh I missed this. Got a reference or link? My Googling is failing me. That's my biggest complaint about Github coming from Gerrit for Open Stack.
- clayallsopp 9mo ago
  not op but I think from https://x.com/jaredpalmer/status/1980619222918262842 https://x.com/jaredpalmer/status/1980619222918262842
  - dvtkrlbs 9mo ago
    https://x.com/jaredpalmer/status/1999525369725215106?s=20 https://x.com/jaredpalmer/status/1999525369725215106?s=20 There is also a concept art (not sure if it is an actual prototype)
dcre 9mo ago
Do you have confidence they can execute?
- everfrustrated 9mo ago
  GitHub have proven the ability to execute very well when they _want_ to. Their product people are top notch. Given the VP of GitHub recently posted a screenshot of their new stacked diff concept on X, I'd be amazed if Graphite folks (whos product is adding this function) didn't get wind of it and look for a quick sell.
  - dcre 9mo ago
    This seems very very implausible to me as an explanation of what prompted them to get acquired. They wanted to get rich and stop having to fundraise!
- steveklabnik 9mo ago
  This was "announced" in October, and last week they were saying they're shipping to trusted partners to kick the tires before a real release, with posted screenshots. So, we'll see what it ends up like, but they have apparently already executed.
  - dcre 9mo ago
    Wow! Didn’t realize.
    - steveklabnik 9mo ago
      These are basically X posts, so it's super easy to miss.
- dvtkrlbs 9mo ago
  I mean this is not a new problem to solve. Git itsels is perfect for this and Gerrit has been doing this for years. So yeah I think they can execute
chucknthem 9mo ago
I've been using git spice (https://abhinav.github.io/git-spice/ https://abhinav.github.io/git-spice/) for the stacked PRs part of graphite and it's been working pretty well and it's open source and free.

joshgachnang 9mo ago

Woahhhhh I missed this. Got a reference or link? My Googling is failing me. That's my biggest complaint about Github coming from Gerrit for Open Stack.

clayallsopp 9mo ago
not op but I think from https://x.com/jaredpalmer/status/1980619222918262842 https://x.com/jaredpalmer/status/1980619222918262842
- dvtkrlbs 9mo ago
  https://x.com/jaredpalmer/status/1999525369725215106?s=20 https://x.com/jaredpalmer/status/1999525369725215106?s=20 There is also a concept art (not sure if it is an actual prototype)

dcre 9mo ago

Do you have confidence they can execute?

everfrustrated 9mo ago
GitHub have proven the ability to execute very well when they _want_ to. Their product people are top notch. Given the VP of GitHub recently posted a screenshot of their new stacked diff concept on X, I'd be amazed if Graphite folks (whos product is adding this function) didn't get wind of it and look for a quick sell.
- dcre 9mo ago
  This seems very very implausible to me as an explanation of what prompted them to get acquired. They wanted to get rich and stop having to fundraise!
steveklabnik 9mo ago
This was "announced" in October, and last week they were saying they're shipping to trusted partners to kick the tires before a real release, with posted screenshots. So, we'll see what it ends up like, but they have apparently already executed.
- dcre 9mo ago
  Wow! Didn’t realize.
  - steveklabnik 9mo ago
    These are basically X posts, so it's super easy to miss.
dvtkrlbs 9mo ago
I mean this is not a new problem to solve. Git itsels is perfect for this and Gerrit has been doing this for years. So yeah I think they can execute

chucknthem 9mo ago

I've been using git spice (https://abhinav.github.io/git-spice/ https://abhinav.github.io/git-spice/) for the stacked PRs part of graphite and it's been working pretty well and it's open source and free.