7 ms·
None of what you said maps onto vibe coding. No one is calling it a toy, and it isn't clunky or unrefined. Claude Code I've heard is refined. The real problem
by betaminecraft 1y ago
None of what you said maps onto vibe coding. No one is calling it a toy, and it isn't clunky or unrefined. Claude Code I've heard is refined.
The real problem with it is that it doesn't work. It isn't "right way wrong way". It doesn't work.
- bitpush 1y agoDid you watch the video that was posted? He literally says 41 seconds in - "[vibe coding is a] naive toytown approach to programming" EDIT: digital cameras didnt work, until it did. streaming didnt work, until it did. ecommerce didnt work, until it did.
- microsoftedging 1y agoI feel like there's a bit of survivorship bias here. Not saying that vibe coding is completely useless, but you still have to review the code it produces in order to make the most of it really. It isn't completely autonomous (yet) to the point where it can scale to any of the examples you mentioned imo.
- Ianjit 1y agoCold fusion didn't work, until it did. 3D TVs didn't work, until they did. Flying cars didn't work, until they did. Satellite phones didn't work, until they did.
- ponector 1y agoNft did work untill they didn't. Supersonic passenger flights did work until they didn't. And many more innovations which are not viable.
- omnicognate 1y agoNaming two successful technologies says nothing. Your steps don't follow inevitably from one to another and there's a vast universe of failed technologies and stillborn revolutions that prove it. If you want to persuade anyone that vibe coding will ultimately replace traditional coding you need to give reasons you think it belongs with digital cameras and streaming and not with lisp machines, ekranoplans and every attempt at "no code" in history. Otherwise you're just making noise.
- betaminecraft 1y ago> digital cameras didnt work, until it did What?
- wapxmas 1y ago"Claude Code I've heard is refined." I've heard, but "The real problem with it is that it doesn't work.". Seems strange.
- betaminecraft 1y ago[flagged]
- kcplate 1y agoYour statement reads as a contradiction of sorts.
- throwaway2016a 1y agoNot OP, but there are many things that I know don't work without trying them. That's not a contradiction. It may or may not be true but it's not a contradiction by itself. You can know reasonable well that something doesn't work by looking at other people who have tried it (sometimes even better if those people are experts and you are not).
- betaminecraft 1y ago[flagged]
- kcplate 1y ago[flagged]
- betaminecraft 1y ago[flagged]
- kcplate 1y ago[flagged]