6 ms·
> That's also an outlier, but less than 30k isn't which makes this post somewhat misleading (at best). I don't disagree that this _isn't_ misleading in a way b
by ThatGeoGuy 3y ago
> That's also an outlier, but less than 30k isn't which makes this post somewhat misleading (at best).
I don't disagree that this _isn't_ misleading in a way but it's also important to consider that most EVs are subject to what you said right after:
> Ford's cars are probably too expensive because they ignored the EV market for a decade and it takes time to scale up production and reduce costs.
Notably that Tesla still isn't at a scale of production where walking off the lot with a < $30k vehicle is possible! There usually isn't a lot to walk off of, but its rare that the base model will be available at all!
Most of the cars they are producing are not the base package, and likely will never be. The thing about supply chains here is that the "base model" is a much smaller percentage of actual manufacturing. Most of the time if a manufacturer were to produce 1M units a year, less than 30% will be the very base model. I'm not sure there are clear numbers published anywhere, but you can bet that while the "base model" might seem affordable you're unlikely to find it due to the same supply chain constraints — Tesla would much rather up-sell you to some package above the base model and availability is restricted as-is, so which customers do you think they'll prioritize? Tesla isn't even producing millions of units yet (I think last year was just over 600k?), and this is just a drop in the bucket in the number of cars purchased each year.
> I'd guess this is because Ford can't profitably make an affordable sedan (they can't do so without losing a lot of money) so they need to make a more expensive vehicle with better margins, Tesla did this too of course - they just had a decade head start while the legacy manufacturers did nothing.
They don't "need" to make larger vehicles with better margins, they just prefer to have better margins. A lot of this is a downstream effect of CAFE exemptions on "light trucks," which applies to both SUVs and modern pick-up trucks. I guess my disagreement here isn't that they "can't" make sedans unless you're defining "can't" in terms of "what the shareholders said." We can absolutely regulate these things and it would probably be beneficial to do so.
As for why Tesla isn't making massive trucks? EV physics (weight of batteries vs. amount of energy to move said weight) somewhat preclude this, but counterpoint there is that Tesla is making a truck and wants to be on top of that market. Sedans are in a weird space with EVs since the added weight kind of puts you in a range<->weight arms race. While most people probably don't need as much range as they think they do, you end up picking between the atrocious Hummer EV or a Model 3 (which is still very large for most of the trips you'd take with a sedan!!!).
- foobarian 3y agoWell, prices aside, there currently is no Ford SUV. I've been shopping for an EV but the current offerings still don't replace my ancient Ford Escape. Still waiting for the electric version...
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoFrom what I understand (and have seen, around here), the new electric "Mustang" is actually a crossover SUV. Note the URL hierarchy. https://www.ford.com/suvs/mach-e/ https://www.ford.com/suvs/mach-e/
- foobarian 3y agoYes, as are most other big brand EVs like Ioniq, Kia's line, etc. But they are still smaller than Escape, not sure if it's a design trend or what. It doesn't seem like there is any inherent constraint in the shape unless it's for air resistance reasons.
- Tagbert 3y agoCrossover, yet, but it hardly qualifies as an SUV. Its overall profile is closer to a medium size sedan with a hatchback. What was once called a 5-door. If the hatch were more vertical it would be closer to traditional station wagons. Yes, Ford markets it as an SUV because that terms appeals to a wider market and most people don’t know what a crossover is.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoa website hierarchy means little; that could be a hack to reuse the existing layouts.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoYou can't walk off the lot with any Tesla, so Tesla has much less influence on what percentage of its cars are the base model than other brands. You order online so there's no salesman standing over you talking you into unneeded upgrades. For high-demand products Tesla will offer a better expected delivery date for more expensive vehicles, but Tesla's supply and demand are in balance now and you can get base model deliveries within a couple of weeks.