6 ms·

The fact that you have to search for the name shows you are not enough clued in about what is happening in India. Wish you take some time out and get the facts

The fact that you have to search for the name shows you are not enough clued in about what is happening in India. Wish you take some time out and get the facts straight from some Indian friends to understand both side of the story. It will become a long comment, all I can say , BBC, NyTimes etc has some axe to grind with the current dispensation.

random314 3y ago
Being Indian, I am clued in well enough. I understand by "Indian friends" you mean upper caste Hindu Indian friends who are Modi acolytes and his primary voting demographic. Not Indian Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Dalits or Shudras who form greater than 50% of the Indian population.
- throwaway_9120 3y ago
  No, I mean people with loads of common sense who can tell you both side of the story. >> Not Indian Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Dalits or Shudras who form greater than 50% of the Indian population. Acc to you, if they are more than 50% AND not happy with Modi, why is Modi winning back to back elections and almost certain to come to power again in 2024?
  - random314 3y ago
    You only need 35% to win in Indias multiparty elections. Additionally, Muslims in Gujarat and UP have been coerced into voting for BJP candidate by threatening them with shut down of municipal services when BJP wins. This is enabled because EVMs report summary statistics from each location which the government employees have access to.
    - throwaway_9120 3y ago
      >> You only need 35% to win in Indias multiparty elections.<< That reinforces my point. >>This is enabled because EVMs<< This EVM story has been peddled by your ilk ad-infinitum but with no substance. If that were the case, BJP should be winning all state elections right? Delhi, WestBengal, Rajasthan… So as and when party of your choice win, EVMs are good when opposition party wins , oh they are manipulated.
      - random314 3y ago
        Did you even read what I said? EVMs are not being tampered. But they make per polling booth data available to candidates. The BJP candidates use that summary data to withhold municipal services from constituents who didn't vote for them. They are able to make this threat because of summary data made available by EVMs https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/maneka-gandhi-s-vote-call-to-muslims-sparks-row/story-w6LaaH7PrpvQGpEwh6n29K.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/maneka-gandhi-s-vo...
        AverageDude 3y ago
        He doesn’t want to read. It’s always hit and run with the fanboys of these authoritarian regimes.
        deleted 3y ago
        [deleted]
        web108 3y ago
        No more interested in further discussion because of HN Guidelines, as suggested by Dan. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
        dang 3y ago
        You also posted several flamewar comments to this thread. This is not ok and we ban accounts that do it. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.
AverageDude 3y ago
Please do something new than the other authoritarian shills. It’s the same playbook. Why do you assume that everyone outside of India is incapable of understanding things on their own and need help from Indian friend? Why do you patronise? Isn’t that racist? Isn’t the that some kind of twisted supremest thinking? I can read the stats and make up my mind on my own.
- throwaway_9120 3y ago
  Of course when you come here with a half-baked knowledge and accuse someone* of astroturfing , one has to call you out. By your own admission, for the first time you heard Nupur’s name, you did a quick search and within minutes you reached the conclusion what you wanted to reach. Since when asking to understand the issue in depth - rather than a 2 mins cursory look up - racism?

random314 3y ago

Being Indian, I am clued in well enough. I understand by "Indian friends" you mean upper caste Hindu Indian friends who are Modi acolytes and his primary voting demographic. Not Indian Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Dalits or Shudras who form greater than 50% of the Indian population.

throwaway_9120 3y ago
No, I mean people with loads of common sense who can tell you both side of the story. >> Not Indian Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Dalits or Shudras who form greater than 50% of the Indian population. Acc to you, if they are more than 50% AND not happy with Modi, why is Modi winning back to back elections and almost certain to come to power again in 2024?
- random314 3y ago
  You only need 35% to win in Indias multiparty elections. Additionally, Muslims in Gujarat and UP have been coerced into voting for BJP candidate by threatening them with shut down of municipal services when BJP wins. This is enabled because EVMs report summary statistics from each location which the government employees have access to.
  - throwaway_9120 3y ago
    >> You only need 35% to win in Indias multiparty elections.<< That reinforces my point. >>This is enabled because EVMs<< This EVM story has been peddled by your ilk ad-infinitum but with no substance. If that were the case, BJP should be winning all state elections right? Delhi, WestBengal, Rajasthan… So as and when party of your choice win, EVMs are good when opposition party wins , oh they are manipulated.
    - random314 3y ago
      Did you even read what I said? EVMs are not being tampered. But they make per polling booth data available to candidates. The BJP candidates use that summary data to withhold municipal services from constituents who didn't vote for them. They are able to make this threat because of summary data made available by EVMs https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/maneka-gandhi-s-vote-call-to-muslims-sparks-row/story-w6LaaH7PrpvQGpEwh6n29K.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/maneka-gandhi-s-vo...
      - AverageDude 3y ago
        He doesn’t want to read. It’s always hit and run with the fanboys of these authoritarian regimes.
        deleted 3y ago
        [deleted]
        web108 3y ago
        No more interested in further discussion because of HN Guidelines, as suggested by Dan. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
        dang 3y ago
        You also posted several flamewar comments to this thread. This is not ok and we ban accounts that do it. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.

AverageDude 3y ago

Please do something new than the other authoritarian shills. It’s the same playbook. Why do you assume that everyone outside of India is incapable of understanding things on their own and need help from Indian friend? Why do you patronise? Isn’t that racist? Isn’t the that some kind of twisted supremest thinking? I can read the stats and make up my mind on my own.

throwaway_9120 3y ago
Of course when you come here with a half-baked knowledge and accuse someone* of astroturfing , one has to call you out. By your own admission, for the first time you heard Nupur’s name, you did a quick search and within minutes you reached the conclusion what you wanted to reach. Since when asking to understand the issue in depth - rather than a 2 mins cursory look up - racism?