9 ms·

Hi. I'm a feature developer for 1Password, and I want to clarify a few things. I've already posted this elsewhere, but I've seen multiple threads spreading misi

Hi. I'm a feature developer for 1Password, and I want to clarify a few things. I've already posted this elsewhere, but I've seen multiple threads spreading misinformation that our technical decisions are being driven by VC funding. This could not be farther from the truth. We have been working on these changes long before we received any form of outside investments. Over the past few years, we've been working on consolidating 1Password's business logic into a single Rust-powered core that could be shared across all our apps. This has many advantages: feature consistency across platforms, faster development cycles, and better security. When building the front-end for the desktop platforms that would take advantage of this new core, Electron suited us perfectly, since we could write our UI code once and make it consistent across Linux, Windows, and Mac. We actually did build a native Mac app initially alongside the cross-platform Electron app, but we eventually decided that having two separate versions of the macOS app (one in Electron, one in SwiftUI) would cause a lot of needless development churn and hassle for both customers and our support team. I can understand your frustrations about Electron and our subscription-based model, but I hope you find my explanation reasonable. Please stop spreading misinformation.

Mindwipe 5y ago
> I've already posted this elsewhere, but I'm seeing some misinformation that our technical decisions are being driven by VC funding. This could not be farther from the truth. We have been working on these changes long before we received any form of outside investments. That's worse, not better. At least being forced to by investors makes sense. The current direction of travel being voluntary means you've just got a bad nose for building security.
- jl_agilebits 5y ago
  > The current direction of travel being voluntary means you've just got a bad nose for building security. Could you elaborate on this?
- movedx 5y ago
  > The current direction of travel being voluntary means you've just got a bad nose for building security. What's your experience building security systems? Do you have a LinkedIn profile or a CV we could review?
neon_electro 5y ago
Hi, long-time user, customer, and word-of-mouth recommender of 1Password for the nine years my Hacker News account has been active (give or take a few months). This is a big announcement that I'll have to chew on to understand what this means. Can you quantify the "needless development churn and hassle for both customers and our support team" in some way? Presumably, 1Password 7 and its ancestors used native macOS APIs, which meant some degree of that given you had to do something different on Windows and/or Linux. I don't know what your support team has had to endure, but as a long-time sample size of 1, I've been incredibly satisfied with the way you've designed and engineered the macOS application (and the iOS app too!) to date; I'd be hopeful that whatever tradeoffs y'all will be making moving to Electron, the "native" feel of the macOS client wouldn't be sacrificed. Is there anything you can speak to there that I should prepare for with 1Password 8?
- jl_agilebits 5y ago
  > Can you quantify the "needless development churn and hassle for both customers and our support team" in some way? Sure, happy to elaborate on that! Since we were rebuilding our app from the ground up, it was a significant slow-down on development to create a user interface for both Electron and SwiftUI, requiring two separate teams of platform developers for every feature we needed to implement. There were also concerns by the documentation and support teams that we would need two separate sets of instructions for many common tasks, due to small differences in layout and look between the applications. Eventually, we had to make the tough decision to focus on a single common framework for desktop. This will allow us to ship features across every single platform far quicker than we could before. > I'd be hopeful that whatever tradeoffs y'all will be making moving to Electron, the "native" feel of the macOS client wouldn't be sacrificed. We've tried our very best to keep the experience the same so that the transition from 7 to 8 is smooth, and from my point of view 1Password 8 feels right at home on macOS - I especially love our new translucent sidebar. That being said, this is still in an early access stage, so there are bound to be hiccups and UI issues that need to be resolved. Please let us know if you run into any problems or have suggestions on how we can improve. And thank you for being a long-time user!
  - 5y ago
mirthflat83 5y ago
I am very unhappy that 1P is moving to Electron for macOS for the reasons people here have reiterated a million times. I am actively looking for alternatives now.
- kenperkins 5y ago
  You'd get rid of a working solution because of an implementation decision? I _love_ 1P, and I use it on Mac, Windows, Linux, and iOS, and it makes perfect sense that they standardize on Electron.
  - vmladenov 5y ago
    > You'd get rid of a working solution because of an implementation decision? Yes, because the implementation decision has implications for both performance and UX. I’ve used 1Password since version 3 (2013!) and gotten friends and family to do the same, but I think I’m done when 7 stops working.
- deadpanPotato 5y ago
  As much as I'm "meh" on Electron, I rarely use the actual 1Password App. On the other hand, I use the Firefox extension 30+ times a day, and that's about as far from a native app as you can get. So I think I'm fairly unlikely to notice a huge issue, and will instead be pleased that consolidating on Electron gives them greater feature velocity.
  - vmladenov 5y ago
    On the other side, I use the 1Password app extensively and make heavy use of all the different categories (secure notes, Windows MSDN licenses, etc). I’m extremely disappointed to see this turn into yet another sub-native browser-in-a-window experience.
    - deadpanPotato 5y ago
      Fair enough! Hopefully the app is as performant as they can possible get from Electron.
Syzygies 5y ago
I'd like to believe this isn't primarily profit motive. What gives me pause is how I write regularly asking for separate vaults for trivial passwords and passwords that could lead to financial ruin. The profit motive wants to keep 1Password simple to use, at the expense of security. I've been forced to buy a second password manager for sensitive passwords.
- jl_agilebits 5y ago
  I'm sorry you feel that way. I'd love to know more about your issues with our current vault implementation in more detail, so I can pass along your feedback to the rest of the development team. > What gives me pause is how I write regularly asking for separate vaults for trivial passwords and passwords that could lead to financial ruin. Just to clarify, what solution are you asking for? Do you want a local vault option to store sensitive passwords? Or something else?
fortuna86 5y ago
So the user hostile changes aren't VC driven, they are internal choices. Ok. How does that change anything?
erichurkman 5y ago
Does that new "core" prevent you from syncing via iCloud?
swiley 5y ago
>would cause a lot of needless development churn and hassle The hassle of doing what your users are paying you to do? Any child can hack a UI together in HTML but there's a reason no one (usually) pays for that.

Mindwipe 5y ago

> I've already posted this elsewhere, but I'm seeing some misinformation that our technical decisions are being driven by VC funding. This could not be farther from the truth. We have been working on these changes long before we received any form of outside investments. That's worse, not better. At least being forced to by investors makes sense. The current direction of travel being voluntary means you've just got a bad nose for building security.

jl_agilebits 5y ago
> The current direction of travel being voluntary means you've just got a bad nose for building security. Could you elaborate on this?
movedx 5y ago
> The current direction of travel being voluntary means you've just got a bad nose for building security. What's your experience building security systems? Do you have a LinkedIn profile or a CV we could review?

neon_electro 5y ago

Hi, long-time user, customer, and word-of-mouth recommender of 1Password for the nine years my Hacker News account has been active (give or take a few months). This is a big announcement that I'll have to chew on to understand what this means. Can you quantify the "needless development churn and hassle for both customers and our support team" in some way? Presumably, 1Password 7 and its ancestors used native macOS APIs, which meant some degree of that given you had to do something different on Windows and/or Linux. I don't know what your support team has had to endure, but as a long-time sample size of 1, I've been incredibly satisfied with the way you've designed and engineered the macOS application (and the iOS app too!) to date; I'd be hopeful that whatever tradeoffs y'all will be making moving to Electron, the "native" feel of the macOS client wouldn't be sacrificed. Is there anything you can speak to there that I should prepare for with 1Password 8?

jl_agilebits 5y ago
> Can you quantify the "needless development churn and hassle for both customers and our support team" in some way? Sure, happy to elaborate on that! Since we were rebuilding our app from the ground up, it was a significant slow-down on development to create a user interface for both Electron and SwiftUI, requiring two separate teams of platform developers for every feature we needed to implement. There were also concerns by the documentation and support teams that we would need two separate sets of instructions for many common tasks, due to small differences in layout and look between the applications. Eventually, we had to make the tough decision to focus on a single common framework for desktop. This will allow us to ship features across every single platform far quicker than we could before. > I'd be hopeful that whatever tradeoffs y'all will be making moving to Electron, the "native" feel of the macOS client wouldn't be sacrificed. We've tried our very best to keep the experience the same so that the transition from 7 to 8 is smooth, and from my point of view 1Password 8 feels right at home on macOS - I especially love our new translucent sidebar. That being said, this is still in an early access stage, so there are bound to be hiccups and UI issues that need to be resolved. Please let us know if you run into any problems or have suggestions on how we can improve. And thank you for being a long-time user!
- 5y ago

mirthflat83 5y ago

I am very unhappy that 1P is moving to Electron for macOS for the reasons people here have reiterated a million times. I am actively looking for alternatives now.

kenperkins 5y ago
You'd get rid of a working solution because of an implementation decision? I _love_ 1P, and I use it on Mac, Windows, Linux, and iOS, and it makes perfect sense that they standardize on Electron.
- vmladenov 5y ago
  > You'd get rid of a working solution because of an implementation decision? Yes, because the implementation decision has implications for both performance and UX. I’ve used 1Password since version 3 (2013!) and gotten friends and family to do the same, but I think I’m done when 7 stops working.
deadpanPotato 5y ago
As much as I'm "meh" on Electron, I rarely use the actual 1Password App. On the other hand, I use the Firefox extension 30+ times a day, and that's about as far from a native app as you can get. So I think I'm fairly unlikely to notice a huge issue, and will instead be pleased that consolidating on Electron gives them greater feature velocity.
- vmladenov 5y ago
  On the other side, I use the 1Password app extensively and make heavy use of all the different categories (secure notes, Windows MSDN licenses, etc). I’m extremely disappointed to see this turn into yet another sub-native browser-in-a-window experience.
  - deadpanPotato 5y ago
    Fair enough! Hopefully the app is as performant as they can possible get from Electron.

Syzygies 5y ago

I'd like to believe this isn't primarily profit motive. What gives me pause is how I write regularly asking for separate vaults for trivial passwords and passwords that could lead to financial ruin. The profit motive wants to keep 1Password simple to use, at the expense of security. I've been forced to buy a second password manager for sensitive passwords.

jl_agilebits 5y ago
I'm sorry you feel that way. I'd love to know more about your issues with our current vault implementation in more detail, so I can pass along your feedback to the rest of the development team. > What gives me pause is how I write regularly asking for separate vaults for trivial passwords and passwords that could lead to financial ruin. Just to clarify, what solution are you asking for? Do you want a local vault option to store sensitive passwords? Or something else?

fortuna86 5y ago

So the user hostile changes aren't VC driven, they are internal choices. Ok. How does that change anything?

erichurkman 5y ago

Does that new "core" prevent you from syncing via iCloud?

swiley 5y ago

>would cause a lot of needless development churn and hassle The hassle of doing what your users are paying you to do? Any child can hack a UI together in HTML but there's a reason no one (usually) pays for that.