8 ms·
So, I tried to think of counter-examples to "most (and possibly all?) early application of mathematics required computation" just for the sake of discussion. I
by nmrm 12y ago
So, I tried to think of counter-examples to "most (and possibly all?) early application of mathematics required computation" just for the sake of discussion.
I think I have only one, which is the establishment of axioms, both philosophically (as a method) and specifically (e.g. in Elements).
A revisionist history might say that choosing axioms doesn't require any computation, just a keen sense of style and close observation of the world.
But actually, I'm sure that the choice of axioms was a long and drawn-out process informed mostly by computation and checks that the computed values/proven theorems matched with physical intuition. After all, that's kind-of how it's done today, even by people who have lots of experience with formal systems.
Now I really want to read pre-Euclidean mathematical philosophy to see if I'm correct :-)
- dllthomas 12y agoYeah, I thought it was interesting space for speculation. 'S why I tried nodding toward it. Don't really know enough of the history to get terribly concrete, but that roughly corresponds to my understanding. Both the actual history and what might be theoretically possible are fascinating.