5 ms·
Think about it like this: In any given sting operation, the John gets arrested, bt there was never any prostitute. The arrest occurs on the basis that, if ther
by ostrakon 13y ago
Think about it like this:
In any given sting operation, the John gets arrested, bt there was never any prostitute. The arrest occurs on the basis that, if there were a prostitute, the John would participate in the exchange. Then, at that point, he's dragged before a judge or jury, and they don't really care about the crime, they just want this guy off the street based on the character assasination. The layman/plebian juror doesn't need to involve any sophisticated thought process, because his goal is to clock out of his "civic duty" by 5PM on the dot. The patrician judge is permitted the luxury of aloof detachment, and is a fallible human being. A person with a social life, biases and any other human weaknesses, despite whatever image or persona they may project into their social sphere of influence.
It doesn't really matter whether the sting is a bomb plot, drug deal, or a setup for hookers, Johns and online chat room predators. The maguffin is there to demonstrate intent, and prove that police are doing there job, the streets are safer, when this slob gets thrown in jail, and branded with a scarlet letter.
But the slob is real, and more often than not, simply being placed in the hot seat is enough for judge and jury to usually be swayed in favor of a conviction. It really doesn't take much for a person to get slapped with a jail sentence. Neither imaginary crimes nor genuine crimes weigh heavily on the mind of your typical juror. Or rather, to the juror, all crimes are essentially the same degree of fiction.
They are tales of intrigue presented to strangers who play the role of critic for a day, while attending the performance of fatal charades.
- Dylan16807 13y agoIt's not really about intent, there has to be a real attempt to commit a crime for your standard sting situation. Drug stings will often go as far as waiting until after a crime has happened to do the arrest. What are you so bitter about?
- pbhjpbhj 13y ago>In any given sting operation, the John gets arrested, bt there was never any prostitute. // I see where you're coming from however it is "soliciting" which is the crime and the perp commits that crime against someone - they just happen not to be a prostitute. At least that's how it plays out in the media. With the [attempted] assassination of an individual you can't have a sting because the main conspirator targets a specific individual [but you can have a sting on a conspiracy charge, so I see how it applies]. It's not like they find their target's not there and decide to just kill a random person. They are only ever concerned with killing a specific person. Now if that specific person doesn't exist then there can't be a killing. With the bomb plot, drug deal, prostitution, child abuser the targets are generalised. The particular nature of the stooge isn't important to the potential perpetrator. If I tell you there's a bank in my town, then we plan a heist, then it turns out that there's no bank. What crime have you committed? [I'm not totally sold on this line I'm presenting incidentally - but thanks for the response anyhow.]