9 ms·
My understanding is that they don't usually end up with stocks, but their handling of this specific situation created what amounted to a short position. Essent
by angli 13y ago
My understanding is that they don't usually end up with stocks, but their handling of this specific situation created what amounted to a short position.
Essentially, the bug (whatever you want to call it is irrelevant from the financial angle) meant a bunch of people wanted to sell facebook stock and were unable to do it. They said that they were willing to sell at the current going rate, which was $42.
NASDAQ was unable to process the orders, so they weren't able to process the sales. The resolution they settled on was essentially becoming the other party to the transaction: they would provide the FB shares to the (possibly disgruntled) customers at the same price - as if nothing had gone wrong.
But, as this is happening, NASDAQ doesn't actually have FB stock - they have to buy it on the market later. Like a normal short, they benefit if the price goes down since they have to spend less to get back the shares. For example, if FB went down $2, NASDAQ only has to pay $40 for the share, and they make a $2 profit.
This is all a long-winded way of saying they didn't have a short in the traditional sense, and in normal cases this doesn't happen, but it happened as a result of this screwup.
- gcb0 13y agostill does not explain "if i want to sell, the exchange should match me with someone. they fail to match me with someone, but instead they buy my shares" makes no sense. at all. unless exchange does not means what i think it means. and they should pay sales tax for shares as they are selling/buying them as a dealership buys and sells cars.
- angli 13y agoNo, exchange still means what you think it means. The issue they had is that a bunch of orders got stuck in a queue somewhere and thus couldn't actually be exchanged. This is all a question of how you deal with that. NASDAQ decided not to just cancel the orders or execute them later but to provide them the trade they "deserved" Personally, I think that was the right decision, but it's your call.