I've seen some work contradicting him, but would be interested in seeing something refuting him. Your phrase "Compelling anecdotal evidence is an oxymoron" see

I've seen some work contradicting him, but would be interested in seeing something refuting him. Your phrase "Compelling anecdotal evidence is an oxymoron" seems strange. If 5 people told me they saw my wallet outside, I'd be compelled to check, by anecdote, if I'd dropped it on my way in. Please show me your science.