13 ms·

> AI music is not and cannot be inspirational. It's the absolute opposite of it. And serious musicians know it. So, your answer to "people are doing a thing" i

> AI music is not and cannot be inspirational. It's the absolute opposite of it. And serious musicians know it. So, your answer to "people are doing a thing" is to just say "no they're not! NANANANA can't hear you!" Musicians have claimed to take inspiration from things like water dripping from a leaky faucet and machine sounds, so your claim that AI outputs can't inspire artists is farcical. You're obviously biased beyond the point of being able to share in a nuanced discourse, the next few years are gonna be SO rough for you, sorry to say. Buckle up.

dofm 4d ago
> Musicians have claimed to take inspiration from things like water dripping from a leaky faucet and machine sounds I don't think you really understand how this very concept undermines your argument. If I saw an artist making creative non-AI work critiquing AI, or even using AI to pointedly critique AI, I would feel differently about that. But I don't think you understand the core concepts here at all. > You're obviously biased beyond the point of being able to share in a nuanced discourse, the next few years are gonna be SO rough for you, sorry to say. Buckle up. This AI industry wizard-of-nihilism tosh gets so old. I am sure you think you're wise and informed and on some kind of nihilist high ground for saying it, though.
- CuriouslyC 4d ago
  No wizardry involved friend, it's pretty clear to see from the way things are playing out now and the history of technological innovation/automation. You are 100% an old man waiving his fist at clouds/time, you will go down just like the scribes and the luddites and the buggy drivers and the portrait painters and the elevator operators. You can make arguments for preferring life before the change, but the change is happening and not accepting it is only self destructive.
  - dofm 4d ago
    And you thought you could criticise me on bias? :-) This is little more than tropes fresh from the blender. (If you read many of my other posts, you will perhaps see that I am a bit more pragmatically engaged with AI than you suggest.)

dofm 4d ago

> Musicians have claimed to take inspiration from things like water dripping from a leaky faucet and machine sounds I don't think you really understand how this very concept undermines your argument. If I saw an artist making creative non-AI work critiquing AI, or even using AI to pointedly critique AI, I would feel differently about that. But I don't think you understand the core concepts here at all. > You're obviously biased beyond the point of being able to share in a nuanced discourse, the next few years are gonna be SO rough for you, sorry to say. Buckle up. This AI industry wizard-of-nihilism tosh gets so old. I am sure you think you're wise and informed and on some kind of nihilist high ground for saying it, though.

CuriouslyC 4d ago
No wizardry involved friend, it's pretty clear to see from the way things are playing out now and the history of technological innovation/automation. You are 100% an old man waiving his fist at clouds/time, you will go down just like the scribes and the luddites and the buggy drivers and the portrait painters and the elevator operators. You can make arguments for preferring life before the change, but the change is happening and not accepting it is only self destructive.
- dofm 4d ago
  And you thought you could criticise me on bias? :-) This is little more than tropes fresh from the blender. (If you read many of my other posts, you will perhaps see that I am a bit more pragmatically engaged with AI than you suggest.)