5 ms·
Very bleak. I think like most people, I would prefer for stories not to be written by AI. I value human creativity, and believe that an LLM cannot truly produce
by fredley 7d ago
Very bleak. I think like most people, I would prefer for stories not to be written by AI. I value human creativity, and believe that an LLM cannot truly produce art.
This article suggests that when people are lied to that stories were not written by AI (when they actually were), they prefer them.
- jake_and_fatman 7d agoFor practical questions, I always prefer Claude's answer to a human's. Non-narcissistic and to the point. For entertainment, I'm less impatient, although unsurprisingly, most people view reading as homework and are happier to blow through a book written at a YA level. Brandon Sanderson a'int the king for nothing.
- p2detar 7d ago"Art is in the eye of the beholder" - it is me, who enjoys art and how it affects me and works with my emotions that is affected by it. Who or what the artist is, should be irrelevant, unless the artist imposes some monetary value I want to profit from at some point.
- jagenabler2 7d agoI don’t think the artist should be irrelevant - the art is the expression of the artist’s emotions. Knowing about the artist unlocks a lot of depth in the art, it’s an attempt to share and express their perspective through creative means. Not to say how you decide to consume art isn’t valid (there is no proper definition after all). However, you’re doing a disservice to a lot of artists by dismissing their role in it all.
- p2detar 7d ago> However, you’re doing a disservice to a lot of artists by dismissing their role in it all. That is a false assumption. I do not dismiss the artist role, but I also would not be interested in the artist if their art does not move me. People generally do not know who Banksy is, but he is being defined by his art, not by his persona. That may very well happen for an AI agent sometime in the future.
- trainingonme 7d agoIt does - but does this not potentially suggest that an LLM can produce "art"?
- robin_reala 7d agoDefine art?
- AndrewDucker 7d agoTo me "art" is the communication of something from the artist, through arrangement of reality, to the person experiencing the art.