21 ms·
What's mine is yours, comrade!!!!
by conartist6 16d ago
What's mine is yours, comrade!!!!
- trimethylpurine 16d agoThe CCP adopted capitalism too. There's no sense in worrying how closely the university aligns real policy with various theoretical economic ideals. If we allow copyright law to directly inhibit technological advancement then we defeat the very purpose of copyright law. That said, it need not inhibit if they just pay for using it. Hopefully they will sue for reasonable compensation, noting that they have such a privilege only in a handful of countries so any restriction is strictly a restriction on those countries, which is a huge technological advantage for all the rest. I try to see both sides.
- conartist6 16d agoYes, just give me my food ration comrade. It is all I need to keep making art for the glory of The Party and it's Supreme Leader. Everything I do I do for the glory of AI. AI is progress!
- trimethylpurine 15d agoPersonally I worry that AI is an existential threat that is totally out of anyone's control by now. Not sure if you read my comment in a different light or not, but I do get the feeling you misunderstood my meaning.
- conartist6 14d agoI don't care what you worry about. What's mine is mine. You can't give it away for me and then say, "as long as they give you a few coins as a token of their appreciation." Would you be happy if I sold your house for $10,000, so long as I give you half the proceeds? Or would you, I dunno, call the police.
- trimethylpurine 14d agoI don't think your analogy is representative of reality. If you copy what my house looks like, no, I won't call the police. Especially if you copy it for the purpose of empowering the police (govt) to protect my actual house. That's a much more accurate analogy.
- conartist6 13d agoMmm, yes. No architects, only police.
- trimethylpurine 12d agoThe architect's financial gain comes second to my safety.
- conartist6 12d agoComrade, of course! That's why I recognized you immediately as a brother in communism. Hail the party, from which all good things come.
- trimethylpurine 10d agoSecond to safety is not the same as non existent. Nice try though.
- doc_ick 15d agoCopyright law can be misused and can inhibit some advancement, but the fact that “certain groups” or “certain companies” can just ignore laws with no ramifications is something else. If it’s probably life-saving or a pipeline of a dream (see Elon musk always promising FSD), then they should pay or prove the end result.
- trimethylpurine 15d agoI agree. You can be right (in my opinion), and stupidly file a bad case (in my opinion), simultaneously. You can be right, and dead at the same time. Just because I think they filed stupid doesn't imply that I think they are wrong.
- doc_ick 15d ago…you’re saying the folks who tried suing OpenAI for accumulating their data filed a stupid copyright? And dead?
- trimethylpurine 14d agoYup. They need to start with the fact that competing nations have access to it no matter what anyone says or does. Negotiate from there.
- doc_ick 13d agoSo for you, everyone should only be good as the worst nation.
- trimethylpurine 12d agoI wouldn't say they should. In some cases there is no other choice. Defense competition exists whether it's desirable or not. Pretending otherwise won't help to win a lawsuit.
- 12d ago