Wow, thanks for your perspective, it’s lucky to find someone on Hacker News who works with technology every day! You presume to know my position but you do not

Wow, thanks for your perspective, it’s lucky to find someone on Hacker News who works with technology every day! You presume to know my position but you do not. AI is an innovative new technology that is radically changing how we build and use technology and will continue to do so. That doesn’t mean that trillions of dollars is going to be spent on it. Despite the penetration all technology has in our lives, most companies are barely using technology from 20 years ago because implementation is a nightmare. Businesses are risk and cost averse, better the line item you know. And so, most companies could be radically improved not by human-level intelligence, or even dog level intelligence, most companies just need macros that are easy to implement. Most companies could 10x their productivity without AI! After all that’s what startups have been doing for the 20 years pre-AI, that’s been the YC investment thesis (which has worked very well). My position is that AI is a radical step forward in technology that pragmatic businesses will benefit from handsomely by using cost effective models. A middle of the road local model that can trigger tools is more than most companies need. The frontier models by the frontier labs are a complete waste of money outside of the most extreme edge cases. Conflating “the technology is incredible” with “companies will spend trillions per year on the technology” is ridiculous. Your argument about usage says absolutely nothing about the financials yet you’re dismissing the AI “doomers” (people who are pessimistic about the financials, not the technology) on that basis. If you look at what we know of the financials of OpenAI and Anthropic it is impossible to come up with a financial case to justify the trillions of dollars in revenue needed for the AI booster’s vision of the future. How much money does The JavaScript Company make? How much money did Docker make? It’s like the AI boosters who argue for the financial case have forgotten the last 20 years. The world of technology is built on open source, it’s built on companies that made a huge impact and failed financially. Docker led the way with containerization, one of the most influential technologies of the last 20 years, and the company almost went under multiple times. We constantly gripe about how unsustainable open source is. Why is all this suddenly different? Why is making an innovative new technology suddenly guaranteeing trillions in revenue? How many trillions of dollars were invested in data centres to build Docker containers? https://xkcd.com/2347/ https://xkcd.com/2347/ why will AI infrastructure be any different? If you think I lack financial literacy, please explain where the money is going to come from. Please make the financial case for trillions of dollars being spent on AI over the next few years. Keep in mind that the reason technology has been so profitable over the last 20 years is because of the margins, software is basically free money. AI is not free money. AI is very expensive money. Also keep in mind that the current (rumored) revenue of Anthropic is primarily made up of the most expensive use case (generating millions of lines of code) being paid for by rich tech companies which does not represent the wider economy. A factory could revolutionize their operations with a middle of the road model they could run on local hardware. Hell, they could revolutionise their operations by hiring a single competent software engineer who understood their business. AI is so compelling because we, technologists, have failed to deliver for most businesses, not because businesses need frontier AI. Bets are meaningless but feel free to stake a claim here to how you think things will be 4 years from now and we can return to review. I’ll stake my claim: AI will be more impactful than ever while Anthropic + OpenAI will have less revenue than today. And we will all be thinking “wtf were we thinking building all these data centres?”