4 ms·

These had a lot of blood sweat and tears poured into them. Most Hollywood game adaptations are the same as the Disney live actions. They have their hands on an

by chomp 21d ago

These had a lot of blood sweat and tears poured into them. Most Hollywood game adaptations are the same as the Disney live actions. They have their hands on an IP, they want to flip it into easy money. Those turn out excruciatingly bad, because for an easy flip, you need to target for mass appeal, which waters down the material.

alephnerd 21d ago
> These had a lot of blood sweat and tears poured into them It goes both ways. Both the video game and the film/tv IP need to have some sort of deeper meaning and writing. You just can't write a cohesive story for a cynical multiplayer FPS like Quake, Wolfenstein II, Doom, etc whose whole appeal in the 1990s and 2000s was gore and shock value. There's a reason people my age (below 35) have never played and oftentimes haven't even heard of Quake or Doom or Wolfenstein but have heard of Fallout or Half Life. > Most Hollywood game adaptations are the same as the Disney live actions. They have their hands on an IP, they want to flip it into easy money... I've given a list of the majority of video game movies created this past decade. They made bank and were well written and have mass appeal.
- everdrive 21d ago
  >You just can't write a cohesive story for a cynical multiplayer FPS like Quake, Wolfenstein II, Doom Except you CAN! Doom and Quake films are begging to just be reskinned Aliens. Begging! I have no idea why someone doesn't just make this film.
  - floren 21d ago
    But you could just watch Aliens.
  - alephnerd 21d ago
    > Except you CAN! Doom and Quake films are begging to just be reskinned Aliens That's my point. The fact that you need to pitch these kinds of games as a knockoff of a better movie shows why they simply aren't viable IP. Nerdy boomer nostalgia ain't cutting it for IP whose entire value was derived from being edgy and shock+gore driven.
    - everdrive 21d ago
      >Nerdy boomer nostalgia What group are you in? My impression is that they have the worst taste of all.
      - alephnerd 21d ago
        > What group are you in Too young to really remember 9/11 but old enough to remember watching the airstrikes on Baghdad in 2003 and the Indian Ocean Tsunami. So I guess I'm technically GenZ or a very very young Millenial. Essentially, I grew up during the PS2, Xbox, GameCube, Xbox360, Wii, and PS3 era. Basically, I'm old, but HNers tend to be a decade or two older.

by chomp 21d ago

alephnerd 21d ago

> These had a lot of blood sweat and tears poured into them It goes both ways. Both the video game and the film/tv IP need to have some sort of deeper meaning and writing. You just can't write a cohesive story for a cynical multiplayer FPS like Quake, Wolfenstein II, Doom, etc whose whole appeal in the 1990s and 2000s was gore and shock value. There's a reason people my age (below 35) have never played and oftentimes haven't even heard of Quake or Doom or Wolfenstein but have heard of Fallout or Half Life. > Most Hollywood game adaptations are the same as the Disney live actions. They have their hands on an IP, they want to flip it into easy money... I've given a list of the majority of video game movies created this past decade. They made bank and were well written and have mass appeal.

everdrive 21d ago
>You just can't write a cohesive story for a cynical multiplayer FPS like Quake, Wolfenstein II, Doom Except you CAN! Doom and Quake films are begging to just be reskinned Aliens. Begging! I have no idea why someone doesn't just make this film.
- floren 21d ago
  But you could just watch Aliens.
- alephnerd 21d ago
  > Except you CAN! Doom and Quake films are begging to just be reskinned Aliens That's my point. The fact that you need to pitch these kinds of games as a knockoff of a better movie shows why they simply aren't viable IP. Nerdy boomer nostalgia ain't cutting it for IP whose entire value was derived from being edgy and shock+gore driven.
  - everdrive 21d ago
    >Nerdy boomer nostalgia What group are you in? My impression is that they have the worst taste of all.
    - alephnerd 21d ago
      > What group are you in Too young to really remember 9/11 but old enough to remember watching the airstrikes on Baghdad in 2003 and the Indian Ocean Tsunami. So I guess I'm technically GenZ or a very very young Millenial. Essentially, I grew up during the PS2, Xbox, GameCube, Xbox360, Wii, and PS3 era. Basically, I'm old, but HNers tend to be a decade or two older.