6 ms·
> The article rests on the claim that water usage of data centers on continent X threaten water availability for humans on continent Y. I don't want to start t
by benrutter 1mo ago
> The article rests on the claim that water usage of data centers on continent X threaten water availability for humans on continent Y.
I don't want to start too much of an off-topic thread within an already off-topic thread, but this isn't a particularly charitable reading. The article itself is mostly laying out information around data centres' resource usage with little prediction for how things would play out. I think statements like:
> The water footprint is equivalent to the minimum annual domestic water needs of roughly 500,000 people in Sub-Saharan Africa
Are clearly just intended as illustrative, rather than a claim that 500,000 people in Sub-Sarah Africa will go without water as a result of AI data centres.
I think the articles head isn't particular good, but it's a fairly moderate take and it's closing message isn't an "AI dooms natural resources" one at all:
> AI within planetary limits is achievable. The report’s central argument is constructive. Capability and stewardship can grow together, but only with measurement, transparency, and shared responsibility across the ecosystem.
At any rate, I definitely don't see any reason this article should be flagged? There's obviously criticisms you can make of it, but that's true of almost any opinion piece that finds itself on the front page here.
- AlexandrB 1mo ago> Are clearly just intended as illustrative, rather than a claim that 500,000 people in Sub-Sarah Africa will go without water as a result of AI data centres. Let's be honest, it's meant to be emotionally manipulative. There are plenty of ways to be illustrative that would make more sense to the target audience, but invoking impoverished folks in Africa is meant to tug at the heart strings.
- KetoManx64 1mo agoThis is also presumably not taking into account the fact that the water is reused/recycled within the data center after it's first brought in.