7 ms·

You can read an explanation of the status codes on the icann website. The explanation for clientRenewProhibited was interesting: "This status code tells your

You can read an explanation of the status codes on the icann website. The explanation for clientRenewProhibited was interesting: "This status code tells your domain's registry to reject requests to renew your domain. It is an uncommon status that is usually enacted during legal disputes or when your domain is subject to deletion." Similar language for some of the other statuses like serverDeleteProhibited. https://www.icann.org/epp#clientRenewProhibited https://www.icann.org/epp#clientRenewProhibited

ivanmontillam 2mo ago
But if you check the domain's expiration date, it's far away in year 2035. To the best of my knowledge, a domain can only be renewed in advance for up to 10 years. (that could be the reason for that status).
- chrisweekly 2mo ago
  (2035 is less than 10 years from now)
  - ivanmontillam 2mo ago
    (Yes, but it expires at 2035-05-20. If you count years by rounding up to integers, there's not enough time room to renew it an additional year. It would make it 11 years.)
    - zamadatix 2mo ago
      Same for dog years, but why are we inventing ways to make it seem more than 10 years out when registries, quite reasonably, just use the date normally?
- mike_d 2mo ago
  > To the best of my knowledge, a domain can only be renewed in advance for up to 10 years. That is the rule for COM/NET/ORG. ccTLDs can do what they please. That said, as a registrar I highly recommend people renew important domains for 9 years. It gives you maximum buffer but allows you to transfer to a new registrar even if your old or new one has the same misconception hard coded.
  - SXX 2mo ago
    What domain zone let you register for more than 10 years?
    - teddyh 2mo ago
      None do at present, AFAIK. But ccTLD could do that, if they wanted to; there is no rule against it, unlike the gTLDs.
      - SXX 2mo ago
        That's weird there no such zones then. It would be nice to be able to pay for a domain 50 years in advance.
        inigyou 2mo ago
        The DNS isn't 50 years old. There's absolutely no certainty your payment for the last year's will mean anything. Also if you're older than 35, you'll probably be dead. If you're not dead you probably won't care about the domain any more. Certainly all current politicians and the current political and economic systems will be dead. It's unclear there will be any reason to still have the domain and that it won't be blocking some innovative economic activity. It's unclear there will still be an internet.
        account42 2mo ago
        It won't protect you against the country hosting the registry being nuked but it will likely shield you from future price hikes because not honoring pas renewals would quickly get the registry a reputation for being a fraud. Which is probably also why there is a limit - no registry wants to be bound by arbitrary long timed liabilities.
        teddyh 2mo ago
        It’s an accounting issue. It is also why all coupons, gift cards, etc. expire. When you buy a domain, or get a coupon, the company basically has to treat that as a debt that the company owes you, and this has to go on the books as a kind of liability. No company want too much of that.
- account42 2mo ago
  No, not being able to renew the domain due to the max renew ahead policy (it's registry-specific but also 10 years for .me) does not result in the clientRenewProhibited flag for .me.
shishcat 2mo ago
I think they just flagged all locks in their admin portal. Like this: https://imgur.com/a/zoTQbwn https://imgur.com/a/zoTQbwn
michalpleban 2mo ago
The status that actually says the domain is suspended is serverHold.
- jonchurch_ 2mo ago
  Came to say this, ICANN says: “This status code is set by your domain's Registry Operator. Your domain is not activated in the DNS.” Also the serverDeleteProhibited status is active, which ICANN also admits is a weird and rare one: “This status code prevents your domain from being deleted. It is an uncommon status that is usually enacted during legal disputes, at your request, or when a redemptionPeriod status is in place.” https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/epp-status-codes-2014-06-16-en#serverhold https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/epp-status-codes-2014-...
  - michalpleban 2mo ago
    Mind you, this is ICANN's description, which applies to global domains and not country domains like .me. Country registries can (and do!) assign different meanings to these statuses; for example in .pl clientRenewProhibited has a completely different meaning.

ivanmontillam 2mo ago

But if you check the domain's expiration date, it's far away in year 2035. To the best of my knowledge, a domain can only be renewed in advance for up to 10 years. (that could be the reason for that status).

chrisweekly 2mo ago
(2035 is less than 10 years from now)
- ivanmontillam 2mo ago
  (Yes, but it expires at 2035-05-20. If you count years by rounding up to integers, there's not enough time room to renew it an additional year. It would make it 11 years.)
  - zamadatix 2mo ago
    Same for dog years, but why are we inventing ways to make it seem more than 10 years out when registries, quite reasonably, just use the date normally?
mike_d 2mo ago
> To the best of my knowledge, a domain can only be renewed in advance for up to 10 years. That is the rule for COM/NET/ORG. ccTLDs can do what they please. That said, as a registrar I highly recommend people renew important domains for 9 years. It gives you maximum buffer but allows you to transfer to a new registrar even if your old or new one has the same misconception hard coded.
- SXX 2mo ago
  What domain zone let you register for more than 10 years?
  - teddyh 2mo ago
    None do at present, AFAIK. But ccTLD could do that, if they wanted to; there is no rule against it, unlike the gTLDs.
    - SXX 2mo ago
      That's weird there no such zones then. It would be nice to be able to pay for a domain 50 years in advance.
      - inigyou 2mo ago
        The DNS isn't 50 years old. There's absolutely no certainty your payment for the last year's will mean anything. Also if you're older than 35, you'll probably be dead. If you're not dead you probably won't care about the domain any more. Certainly all current politicians and the current political and economic systems will be dead. It's unclear there will be any reason to still have the domain and that it won't be blocking some innovative economic activity. It's unclear there will still be an internet.
        account42 2mo ago
        It won't protect you against the country hosting the registry being nuked but it will likely shield you from future price hikes because not honoring pas renewals would quickly get the registry a reputation for being a fraud. Which is probably also why there is a limit - no registry wants to be bound by arbitrary long timed liabilities.
      - teddyh 2mo ago
        It’s an accounting issue. It is also why all coupons, gift cards, etc. expire. When you buy a domain, or get a coupon, the company basically has to treat that as a debt that the company owes you, and this has to go on the books as a kind of liability. No company want too much of that.
account42 2mo ago
No, not being able to renew the domain due to the max renew ahead policy (it's registry-specific but also 10 years for .me) does not result in the clientRenewProhibited flag for .me.

shishcat 2mo ago

I think they just flagged all locks in their admin portal. Like this: https://imgur.com/a/zoTQbwn https://imgur.com/a/zoTQbwn

michalpleban 2mo ago

The status that actually says the domain is suspended is serverHold.

jonchurch_ 2mo ago
Came to say this, ICANN says: “This status code is set by your domain's Registry Operator. Your domain is not activated in the DNS.” Also the serverDeleteProhibited status is active, which ICANN also admits is a weird and rare one: “This status code prevents your domain from being deleted. It is an uncommon status that is usually enacted during legal disputes, at your request, or when a redemptionPeriod status is in place.” https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/epp-status-codes-2014-06-16-en#serverhold https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/epp-status-codes-2014-...
- michalpleban 2mo ago
  Mind you, this is ICANN's description, which applies to global domains and not country domains like .me. Country registries can (and do!) assign different meanings to these statuses; for example in .pl clientRenewProhibited has a completely different meaning.