6 ms·
Apparently, whether or not the engineers are Chinese is the deciding factor. as long as Nicklas Backstrom is designing the EV, its all good. Or in other words,
by cwel 3mo ago
Apparently, whether or not the engineers are Chinese is the deciding factor. as long as Nicklas Backstrom is designing the EV, its all good. Or in other words, Chinese scary!
- teravor 3mo ago> Chinese scary! Chinese nationals should be assumed to act on behalf of China, it really isn't difficult to understand even for pathologically empathetic people.
- wat10000 3mo agoThat's fine, but what stops those Chinese nationals at Geely from messing with their cars now?
- teravor 3mo agodo you have evidence that if they wanted to do that they would not be giving orders to European or American engineers? as I said, financial fictions don't matter in matters such as these. if you have evidence that they have Chinese nationals working as engineers without oversight, you should submit it to the government.
- wat10000 3mo ago“Give us the signing keys to the software update servers.” “No.” You really think that’s how that conversation would go?
- teravor 3mo agono. first you need to design the pathway by which control of the computers will allow overriding control over all the relevant control surfaces, something Tesla for example doesn't do. for that you need engineers collaborating all along.
- wat10000 3mo agoI don't understand what you mean. I assumed the scenario was the manufacturer bricking the car, starting it on fire, or making it crash. Bricking is pretty obviously trivial. Starting it on fire would require changes to the battery, motor, or charger firmware, no big deal. Making it crash requires control over steering, motor, and brakes, which any car with modern driver assist features already has. What part of this would a Tesla, or any other car, not be able to do?
- teravor 3mo ago> What part of this would a Tesla, or any other car, not be able to do? Tesla computers are not capable of maintaining steering control when the user is physically moving the steering wheel. does BYD have similar restrictions? can you trust them? this discussion has reached the limit of its usefulness. if you aren't able to see why having nationals in an adversary nation be in control of dangerous hardware on your soil is a big problem, nothing will aid you in understanding this.
- wat10000 3mo agoThat's not the point of disagreement. I completely see why that's a big problem. Where we disagree is the notion that Volvo isn't controlled by an adversary nation or doesn't have dangerous hardware. If you've managed to come away from this discussion with the impression that I think it's no big deal to have adversaries in control of dangerous hardware on your soil, then I do have to agree that this discussion has reached the limit of its usefulness, because I said nothing of the kind.
- cwel 3mo ago> Chinese nationals should be assumed to act on behalf of China I acknowledged this, you quoted it. > it really isn't difficult to understand... Where does 'it' end? Is the subsidiary not operating at the behest of their parent? I need to know when it's safe to no longer be scared.
- teravor 3mo ago> Where does 'it' end? Is the subsidiary not operating at the behest of their parent? corporations are financial fictions. the risk I am discussing is literally the mass destruction and murder of civilians during a time of war. individuals carrying it out will be subject to sanctions (including elimination), only those who are protected by their government will carry out such instructions. and therefore national security focuses on firms which have engineers that are protected thus.
- cwel 3mo agoOh, so the point is that cars are scary. true, you have unlocked +1t in funding for the DoD.
- inigyou 3mo agoSwedish nationals should be assumed to act on behalf of Sweden.