5 ms·
I have asked LLMs several Emacs-related questions and _never_ got a reply that works. And at generating elisp code they are especially awful.
by tapete1 3mo ago
I have asked LLMs several Emacs-related questions and _never_ got a reply that works. And at generating elisp code they are especially awful.
- antiframe 3mo agoThat is not my experience. I had Claude add a variety of useful functions to my init.el as well as refactor it for easier maintenance. I now have a more useful to use and pleasant to edit init for it.
- neutronicus 3mo agoYeah, Claude has helped me fix a bunch of warts I was just living with.
- SoftTalker 3mo agoSame. I'm not an elisp expert by any means, so I tried using claude and chatgpt to help me write some functions. They got close, close enough that I could massage what they wrote into something that did what I needed, but they have never produced anything that just worked.
- jr_isidore 3mo agoTry asking it a coding question, one that doesn't diminish your self-worth.
- mrhottakes 3mo agoAgreed, Claude didn't seem capable of doing anything but hallucinating "fixes" and breaking my config.
- cmrdporcupine 3mo agoNot my experience. I've had them write modes for new languages from scratch with excellent results. And diagnose and fix up my emacs configuration. Even back in pre-Opus 4.5 days I found them incredibly useful for elisp diagnostics, and these days I use Codex to great effect to enhance my emacs setup.