5 ms·
Read the fourth amendment since you clearly didn't the first time.
by Vicinity9635 8mo ago
Read the fourth amendment since you clearly didn't the first time.
- otterley 8mo agoAs an attorney, I can tell you that a naive reading of words in the Constitution is not how law is decided.
- Vicinity9635 8mo agoBelieve it or not, I don't care what authoritarians feel about the 4th amendment that was designed to be read and interpreted free of the courts.
- jazzyjackson 8mo agoI suppose you tell cops at a traffic stop that you don't need a license plate because you're an individual not engaging in commerce.
- otterley 8mo agoAnd how, exactly, are you certain of this intended design?
- Vicinity9635 8mo ago"shall not be violated" leaves no loopholes. Just like the second amendment: >A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed. "shall not be infringed" and "shall not be violated" do not leave loopholes. It's quite clear.
- otterley 8mo agoI didn’t ask you what the words say; anyone can read them. I asked you why you believe, based on the historical evidence, that the Constitution isn’t supposed to be interpreted by our courts.
- Vicinity9635 8mo agoI answered your question. Your failure of comprehension is not my problem.
- otterley 8mo agoYou did not. This is the answer of someone who has lost the argument and knows it, but refuses to admit it. The door is that way; kindly let yourself out.
- Vicinity9635 8mo agoSince you're pretending to be a lawyer and losing an argument I'll highlight the part that answers the question: >"shall not be infringed" and "shall not be violated" do not leave loopholes. It's quite clear.
- otterley 8mo agoI am not pretending to be a lawyer and will happily send you my bona fides. Feel free to email me at otterley at otterley dot org.
- parineum 8mo agoThere's a branch of government who's job is to write laws, who's job is to interpret laws and one who's job is to enforce laws. Which one are you?
- Vicinity9635 8mo ago[dead]
- parineum 8mo agoYou are a person, not the people. I disagree with you on what the Constitution says. Luckily, The Constitution outlines how to resolve that dispute. [0] > ... Abraham Lincoln November 19, 1863 Abraham Lincoln was four score and seven years late to the founding, I'm not sure what his opinion has to do with it. [0]https://constitutioncenter.org/the-constitution/articles/article-iii https://constitutioncenter.org/the-constitution/articles/art...
- Starlevel004 8mo agoThe Fourth Amendment only applies to places flying a flag with gold fringes