6 ms·

Same as modals?

• bradleyy 9mo ago
  Modals are, IMO, the literal worst UX element you can hate your users with. There are certainly valid use cases, but _absolutely not_ should be the default.
  • licorices 9mo ago
    How come? I find them nice to allow for certain actions that don't really require navigation, and may want the user to easily return whenever they do anything in the modal or not. I understand it is historically bad due to accessibility, but there's more native support for it now. Assuming it is implemented with that in mind, is it still bad?
    • bradleyy 9mo ago
      Modals are... modal. Popping up a dialog that requires interaction, while blocking access to the rest of the application. Again, this is sometimes appropriate, but it's desperately wrong in so many places it gets used.
• herpdyderp 9mo ago
  I personally don't find modals inherently all that bad, though they can definitely be implemented poorly. Does anyone have specific reading material on the problems with modals?