4 ms·

Runc breaks pods when CPU requests aren't multiples of 10

39 points by dropbox_miner 10mo ago

dfajgljsldkjag 10mo ago
Whether this is a real bug or not, the fact that the entire report is LLM generated AI slop makes my eyes glaze over. I'm sure it's also a waste of maintainers time to drop a wall of AI bullet points instead of just sharing the critical information.
- monus 10mo ago
  Agreed. Use LLM all you want to do the discovery and proof but do not use it to replace your voice. I literally can’t read, my brain just shuts off when I see LLM text.
- nullpoint420 10mo ago
  It’s crazy how they just copied and pasted it
  - geraneum 10mo ago
    Maybe it’s not even a copy paste. Just something running in a loop, interacting with LLMs and automatically calling APIs.
- radarsat1 10mo ago
  It is a strange phenomenon though, these walls of text that LLMs output, when you consider that one thing they're really good at is summarization, and that if they are trained on bug report data, you'd think they would reproduce it in terms of style and conciseness. Is it mainly post-training that causes this behaviour? They seem to do it for everything, like they are really biased towards super verbose output these days. Maybe something to do with reasoning models being trained for longer output?
shakna 10mo ago
Oh yay. More AI powered slop. And I do mean slop. It was fixed already: https://github.com/opencontainers/runc/pull/4751 https://github.com/opencontainers/runc/pull/4751 So the bot goes ahead and spams every project that has already done the work. And unrelated ones. Whilst also leaking that this is to do with a GEO-location project building a cluster on AWS, for Accenture. Probably government contract.
- miyuru 10mo ago
  Hostname points to an insurance company. "ip-10-7-66-184.prod-eks.newfront.com"
  - shakna 10mo ago
    Author's profile points to a member of Accenture's ADVANCE team, who specialise currently in AI powered infrastructure. The insurance company is the client getting their info dumped by a careless approach. But I didn't really want to dox the client.
EdwardDiego 10mo ago
I was going to say "Needs more emojis", then I scrolled down, and phew! Purple tick box emojis! I was worried a human was in the loop for a second. Thank God for LLM! > Thank you for the context! That makes sense - runc is correctly rounding to 10ms (410000) as systemd requires. You're absolutely right! I shall now commit ritualised suicide based on your feedback! <arrow in target emoji> Having the AI reply to comments is almost like a direct insult.
- deleted 10mo ago
  [deleted]
- elmigranto 10mo ago
  Purple tick box is how GitHub formats links to merged PRs and closed issues.
  - EdwardDiego 10mo ago
    Nope, it's how Claude formats ticks, apparently.
dropbox_miner 10mo ago
This makes me worry about the direction in which open source is headed. There is an issue opened now to talk about LLM Generated issues: https://github.com/opencontainers/runc/issues/4990 https://github.com/opencontainers/runc/issues/4990

39 points by dropbox_miner 10mo ago

Whether this is a real bug or not, the fact that the entire report is LLM generated AI slop makes my eyes glaze over. I'm sure it's also a waste of maintainers time to drop a wall of AI bullet points instead of just sharing the critical information.

monus 10mo ago
Agreed. Use LLM all you want to do the discovery and proof but do not use it to replace your voice. I literally can’t read, my brain just shuts off when I see LLM text.
nullpoint420 10mo ago
It’s crazy how they just copied and pasted it
- geraneum 10mo ago
  Maybe it’s not even a copy paste. Just something running in a loop, interacting with LLMs and automatically calling APIs.
radarsat1 10mo ago
It is a strange phenomenon though, these walls of text that LLMs output, when you consider that one thing they're really good at is summarization, and that if they are trained on bug report data, you'd think they would reproduce it in terms of style and conciseness. Is it mainly post-training that causes this behaviour? They seem to do it for everything, like they are really biased towards super verbose output these days. Maybe something to do with reasoning models being trained for longer output?

shakna 10mo ago

Oh yay. More AI powered slop. And I do mean slop. It was fixed already: https://github.com/opencontainers/runc/pull/4751 https://github.com/opencontainers/runc/pull/4751 So the bot goes ahead and spams every project that has already done the work. And unrelated ones. Whilst also leaking that this is to do with a GEO-location project building a cluster on AWS, for Accenture. Probably government contract.

miyuru 10mo ago
Hostname points to an insurance company. "ip-10-7-66-184.prod-eks.newfront.com"
- shakna 10mo ago
  Author's profile points to a member of Accenture's ADVANCE team, who specialise currently in AI powered infrastructure. The insurance company is the client getting their info dumped by a careless approach. But I didn't really want to dox the client.

EdwardDiego 10mo ago

I was going to say "Needs more emojis", then I scrolled down, and phew! Purple tick box emojis! I was worried a human was in the loop for a second. Thank God for LLM! > Thank you for the context! That makes sense - runc is correctly rounding to 10ms (410000) as systemd requires. You're absolutely right! I shall now commit ritualised suicide based on your feedback! <arrow in target emoji> Having the AI reply to comments is almost like a direct insult.

deleted 10mo ago
[deleted]
elmigranto 10mo ago
Purple tick box is how GitHub formats links to merged PRs and closed issues.
- EdwardDiego 10mo ago
  Nope, it's how Claude formats ticks, apparently.

dropbox_miner 10mo ago

This makes me worry about the direction in which open source is headed. There is an issue opened now to talk about LLM Generated issues: https://github.com/opencontainers/runc/issues/4990 https://github.com/opencontainers/runc/issues/4990