6 ms·

This is possibly what I want? It's hard to tell from all of the marketing on the site. I want to run a prompt that operates in an isolated environment that is

by mdeeks 11mo ago

This is possibly what I want? It's hard to tell from all of the marketing on the site. I want to run a prompt that operates in an isolated environment that is open in my IDE where I can iterate with the AI. I think maybe it can do this?

simonw 11mo ago
Not quite. This doesn't (yet) have an option where you can connect your local IDE to their remote containers to edit files directly. It's more of a fire-and-forget thing where you can eventually suck the resulting code down to your local machine using "claude --teleport ..." - but then it's not running in the cloud any more.
- tomvault 11mo ago
  CEO at Ona (formerly Gitpod) here. Every ephemeral environment Ona creates can directly connect to your Desktop IDE for easy handoff. Our team goes from prompt -> iterating in conversation -> VS Code Web -> VS Code Desktop/Cursor depending on task complexity and quality of the agent output. We call this progressive engagement and have written about it here https://ona.com/docs/ona/best-practices#progressive-engagement%3A-conversation-%E2%86%92-vs-code-web-%E2%86%92-desktop-ide https://ona.com/docs/ona/best-practices#progressive-engageme...
  - mdeeks 11mo ago
    Thanks, I'll give it a shot. I wish your site would show me what it actually looks like. It's a lot of words and fancy marketing images and I have no feel for the product. It leaves me unsure if I should invest my time. I'd love to see a short animation of what it would actually look like to do the core flow. Prompt -> environment creation -> iterating -> popping open VSCode Web -> Popping open Cursor desktop. Also, a lot of the links on that page you linked me to are broken: * "manual edits and Ona Agents is very powerful." * "Ona’s automations.yaml extends it with tasks and services" * "devcontainer.json describes the tools"
    - mdeeks 11mo ago
      I signed up and tried it with Cursor. It is very close, but still has a lot of rough edges that make it hard to switch: * Once in Cursor I can't click on modified files or lines and have my IDE jump to it. Very hard to review changes. * I closed the Ona tab and couldn't figure out how to get it back so I could prompt it again. * I can't pin the Ona tab to the right like Cursor does * Is there a way to select lines and add them to context? * Is there a way I can pick a model?

by mdeeks 11mo ago

simonw 11mo ago

Not quite. This doesn't (yet) have an option where you can connect your local IDE to their remote containers to edit files directly. It's more of a fire-and-forget thing where you can eventually suck the resulting code down to your local machine using "claude --teleport ..." - but then it's not running in the cloud any more.

tomvault 11mo ago
CEO at Ona (formerly Gitpod) here. Every ephemeral environment Ona creates can directly connect to your Desktop IDE for easy handoff. Our team goes from prompt -> iterating in conversation -> VS Code Web -> VS Code Desktop/Cursor depending on task complexity and quality of the agent output. We call this progressive engagement and have written about it here https://ona.com/docs/ona/best-practices#progressive-engagement%3A-conversation-%E2%86%92-vs-code-web-%E2%86%92-desktop-ide https://ona.com/docs/ona/best-practices#progressive-engageme...
- mdeeks 11mo ago
  Thanks, I'll give it a shot. I wish your site would show me what it actually looks like. It's a lot of words and fancy marketing images and I have no feel for the product. It leaves me unsure if I should invest my time. I'd love to see a short animation of what it would actually look like to do the core flow. Prompt -> environment creation -> iterating -> popping open VSCode Web -> Popping open Cursor desktop. Also, a lot of the links on that page you linked me to are broken: * "manual edits and Ona Agents is very powerful." * "Ona’s automations.yaml extends it with tasks and services" * "devcontainer.json describes the tools"
  - mdeeks 11mo ago
    I signed up and tried it with Cursor. It is very close, but still has a lot of rough edges that make it hard to switch: * Once in Cursor I can't click on modified files or lines and have my IDE jump to it. Very hard to review changes. * I closed the Ona tab and couldn't figure out how to get it back so I could prompt it again. * I can't pin the Ona tab to the right like Cursor does * Is there a way to select lines and add them to context? * Is there a way I can pick a model?