7 ms·
> While scientists have considered accessing the liquid to further analyze the content, as of 2024, the bottle has remained unopened because of concerns about h
by 4ad 1y ago
> While scientists have considered accessing the liquid to further analyze the content, as of 2024, the bottle has remained unopened because of concerns about how the liquid would react when exposed to air.
...This seems like a trivial non-concern? Just open it in an inert atmosphere?
> While it has reportedly lost its ethanol content
Why, and more importantly how would it lose its ethanol content?
- glitchc 1y agoNo bottle can guarantee an absolute seal. Even a very tiny leak will allow ethanol to evaporate over time.
- throwup238 1y ago> Why, and more importantly how would it lose its ethanol content? Most wine bottles lose their ethanol within decades because oxygen makes it through the seal and the ethanol evaporates or reacts into something else. Any wine bottle that survives to hundreds of years old, even perfectly sealed, will have bacteria converting ethanol to acetaldehyde and acetic acid via aerobic and anaerobic pathways. 200-300 years is normally the limit before wine loses all ethanol even without a leak.
- Nexxius 1y agoWhich bring to mind those bottles of Napoleon era champagne found preserved under pressure in a ship wreck. Any info on how those turned out or was the one opened a palatable vinegar?
- the8472 1y agoPerhaps with a dash of cobalt-60 we can ensure both a long shelf-life and discourage premature opening.
- owenversteeg 1y agoSorry, your comment is bullshit. >Most wine bottles lose their ethanol within decades Not true at all, even for bottles sealed with cheap, short corks, or bottles that leak. One delicious example is 1977 Vintage Port, which is notorious for faulty corks. Roughly speaking, 1/3 to 1/2 of corks failed even with good storage. And yet - the port inside is still in near-perfect shape, alcohol intact. Indeed, I just opened another bottle of '77 Dow's the night before last, and it was flawless. >200-300 years is normally the limit before wine loses all ethanol even without a leak. Also entirely untrue - I have wine in that age range as well :) And once again, some of it has leaked, and once again, the alcohol remained intact... If you don't believe me, I recommend looking up tasting notes for old wines. There are plenty of datapoints on this particular subject. Or, you could buy a bottle! Vintage Port with fifty years on it isn't terribly expensive for the quality and age of wine you're buying.