6 ms·

I don't trust Google reviews anymore, Maps or otherwise. Look at how many reviews will just be five-star ones, but no text. Or, one or two words quips, like, "

I don't trust Google reviews anymore, Maps or otherwise. Look at how many reviews will just be five-star ones, but no text. Or, one or two words quips, like, "great food!" Negative reviews might also be emotionally driven, some by one-time events, like a to-go order taking too long because of a large office order that preceded it. When I was apartment shopping, I saw so many "sketchy" reviews on Google and reporting them does nothing. Many would be from people who only toured the place and NEVER actually lived there, or from people who just moved in. Both are useless, but does Google care? No! Hence, my disdain for Google reviews.

alephnan 2y ago
We need something like Amazon Fake Reviews but for Google reviews. Amazon Fake Reviews also stopped being reliable because people figured out how to game it.
dmortin 2y ago
> I don't trust Google reviews anymore, Maps or otherwise. What do you use as alternative?
- nottorp 2y ago
  Any review site is kinda worthless. What you can do is go through the text reviews and try to read between the lines and figure out if the place/item is good for you.
  - xarope 2y ago
    if only LLMs could be used for this... business idea anybody?
    - laurynas-s 2y ago
      https://www.top-rated.online/cities/Rome/place/p/10807332/Trevi+Fountain https://www.top-rated.online/cities/Rome/place/p/10807332/Tr... here you go
    - nottorp 2y ago
      > business idea anybody? How do you make money without skewing the results? And can LLMs be subtle enough? Last time I picked a restaurant via reading between the lines, it was a negative review that made me decide to go there. The person leaving it was either used to fast food like service or was in a real hurry, but between the lines the food was great, they just took a while to serve it. I was in no particular hurry so I was happy with the place. Can a LLM figure that out? And what about the day when I am in a hurry and I am looking for fast food like service?
- speedgoose 2y ago
  Friends, family, and guides like Guide Michelin for me.
laurynas-s 2y ago
It is quite time-consuming to go through the reviews due to this exact reason - 100s of low effort reviews and also fake reviews to hide negative reviews. https://www.top-rated.online/ https://www.top-rated.online/ re-sorts the reviews (on individual place page) based on reactions and number of reviews user made. It makes it easier to see the full picture and avoid fake reviews.

alephnan 2y ago

We need something like Amazon Fake Reviews but for Google reviews. Amazon Fake Reviews also stopped being reliable because people figured out how to game it.

dmortin 2y ago

> I don't trust Google reviews anymore, Maps or otherwise. What do you use as alternative?

nottorp 2y ago
Any review site is kinda worthless. What you can do is go through the text reviews and try to read between the lines and figure out if the place/item is good for you.
- xarope 2y ago
  if only LLMs could be used for this... business idea anybody?
  - laurynas-s 2y ago
    https://www.top-rated.online/cities/Rome/place/p/10807332/Trevi+Fountain https://www.top-rated.online/cities/Rome/place/p/10807332/Tr... here you go
  - nottorp 2y ago
    > business idea anybody? How do you make money without skewing the results? And can LLMs be subtle enough? Last time I picked a restaurant via reading between the lines, it was a negative review that made me decide to go there. The person leaving it was either used to fast food like service or was in a real hurry, but between the lines the food was great, they just took a while to serve it. I was in no particular hurry so I was happy with the place. Can a LLM figure that out? And what about the day when I am in a hurry and I am looking for fast food like service?
speedgoose 2y ago
Friends, family, and guides like Guide Michelin for me.

laurynas-s 2y ago

It is quite time-consuming to go through the reviews due to this exact reason - 100s of low effort reviews and also fake reviews to hide negative reviews. https://www.top-rated.online/ https://www.top-rated.online/ re-sorts the reviews (on individual place page) based on reactions and number of reviews user made. It makes it easier to see the full picture and avoid fake reviews.