5 ms·

Do such kinds of experiments confound our search for extraterrestrial life? Mars and moon missions could introduce tiny life forms, that could be released into

Do such kinds of experiments confound our search for extraterrestrial life? Mars and moon missions could introduce tiny life forms, that could be released into the environment. Some of these are extremely hardy (such as tardigrades) which could then start proliferating when conditions are right.

ravenstine 2y ago
They'd definitely muddy the water, but wouldn't genetics confirm whether a life form is from Earth? (assuming other life even has anything resembling our form of genetics)
- sulam 2y ago
  No, not least because the panspermia hypothesis says that DNA is in fact not originally from Earth.
accrual 2y ago
Yep! There is very real concern about accidentally introducing Earth life on others moons and planets, and then "discovering" the introduced life instead of actual native life. As you mentioned with tardigrades, there are life forms and bacteria that could possibly survive a long duration flight through the vacuum of space, then proliferate once it reaches the surface somewhere. This is usually guarded against by various sterilization techniques applied to the spacecraft before launch, and there is a discipline dedicated to ensuring these events don't happen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_protection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_protection
evilduck 2y ago
Mars, Earth and the Moon are close enough neighbors that rocks which could harbor life are already exchanged between them during impact events. Life found in deep granite rock on Earth: https://academic.oup.com/femsre/article/20/3-4/399/516507 https://academic.oup.com/femsre/article/20/3-4/399/516507 This recent one even discusses Mars being the origin of life and seeding Earth (panspermia) https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/10/241003123543.htm#:~:text=10/241003123543.htm-,Pockets%20of%20microbes%20have%20been%20found%20living%20within%20a%20sealed,samples%20brought%20back%20from%20Mars https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/10/241003123543.h.... Mars rocks found on Earth: https://www.space.com/mars-meteorites-on-earth-mystery https://www.space.com/mars-meteorites-on-earth-mystery Mars rocks being plausible candidates for harboring life: https://www.planetary.org/articles/nasa-discovers-mars-rock-with-ancient-potential-for-life https://www.planetary.org/articles/nasa-discovers-mars-rock-... I think reasonable caution by space agencies is wise but it also could have already happened a billion years ago. If we want to survive as a species or lineage of species beyond the Sun enveloping the Earth we will also need to deliberately establish viable life on other planets and even other solar systems at some point, previous historical records of ancestral life or present planetary sterility be damned. Life seems too rare in the universe for it to go down with the ship, we should make an effort to duplicate this experiment even if humanity doesn't make it.

ravenstine 2y ago

They'd definitely muddy the water, but wouldn't genetics confirm whether a life form is from Earth? (assuming other life even has anything resembling our form of genetics)

sulam 2y ago
No, not least because the panspermia hypothesis says that DNA is in fact not originally from Earth.

accrual 2y ago

Yep! There is very real concern about accidentally introducing Earth life on others moons and planets, and then "discovering" the introduced life instead of actual native life. As you mentioned with tardigrades, there are life forms and bacteria that could possibly survive a long duration flight through the vacuum of space, then proliferate once it reaches the surface somewhere. This is usually guarded against by various sterilization techniques applied to the spacecraft before launch, and there is a discipline dedicated to ensuring these events don't happen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_protection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_protection

evilduck 2y ago

Mars, Earth and the Moon are close enough neighbors that rocks which could harbor life are already exchanged between them during impact events. Life found in deep granite rock on Earth: https://academic.oup.com/femsre/article/20/3-4/399/516507 https://academic.oup.com/femsre/article/20/3-4/399/516507 This recent one even discusses Mars being the origin of life and seeding Earth (panspermia) https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/10/241003123543.htm#:~:text=10/241003123543.htm-,Pockets%20of%20microbes%20have%20been%20found%20living%20within%20a%20sealed,samples%20brought%20back%20from%20Mars https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/10/241003123543.h.... Mars rocks found on Earth: https://www.space.com/mars-meteorites-on-earth-mystery https://www.space.com/mars-meteorites-on-earth-mystery Mars rocks being plausible candidates for harboring life: https://www.planetary.org/articles/nasa-discovers-mars-rock-with-ancient-potential-for-life https://www.planetary.org/articles/nasa-discovers-mars-rock-... I think reasonable caution by space agencies is wise but it also could have already happened a billion years ago. If we want to survive as a species or lineage of species beyond the Sun enveloping the Earth we will also need to deliberately establish viable life on other planets and even other solar systems at some point, previous historical records of ancestral life or present planetary sterility be damned. Life seems too rare in the universe for it to go down with the ship, we should make an effort to duplicate this experiment even if humanity doesn't make it.