7 ms·
OS window managers do a better job of that. Split view inside the browser has some thorny issues around making sure the user knows what resource they are intera
by kbrosnan 2y ago
OS window managers do a better job of that. Split view inside the browser has some thorny issues around making sure the user knows what resource they are interacting with. There is a lot of complexity when it comes to focus/blur in HTML, CSS, JS, etc.
- thomasahle 2y agoThe cat was out of the bag, when browsers got tabs. They are already tiny window managers, and may as well lean into it.
- kbrosnan 2y agoTabs state management is simpler and more battle tested. Split pane browsers will need to relearn some of the same problems/security found when tabed browsing was introduced. They will have unique problems/security as well. I would be interested to see how split pane browsers deal with focus stealing JS especially with timeouts or other shenanigans.
- sureIy 2y agoNo they’re not. Tabs are tabs, they’re not windows. Next thing you tell me is that they should implement virtual desktops and loading tabs remotely. They are already tiny window managers, and may as well lean into it.
- rpncreator 2y agoUnpopular opinion: Tab management in browsers originally addressed the shortcomings of OS window management (see Windows XP and IE6, and the original Google Chrome tiling capability replicated into Windows 10/11 OS window management.
- kevincox 2y agoI also share this opinion. I think we are in a local maximum with tabs. But getting out of it request a lot of coordination between browsers and each desktop environment so it is unlikely to ever happen. Maybe less portable browsers like GNOME Web or Safari that only "need" to deal with one desktop environment can manage it at some point. https://kevincox.ca/2021/01/11/tabs-were-a-mistake/ https://kevincox.ca/2021/01/11/tabs-were-a-mistake/