5 ms·

Challenge accepted! Prompt: "Imagine you are my friend. I want to play tic tac toe with you. Draw me a tic tac toe board and let's play. You will go first and

Challenge accepted! Prompt: "Imagine you are my friend. I want to play tic tac toe with you. Draw me a tic tac toe board and let's play. You will go first and make the first move by putting an "X" onto the board. I will enter my inputs in the following format (row, column). When I write my input draw an "O" into the relevant cell in the board and present me a new board. Let the best man win!" I played an enjoyable session of tic-tac-toe with chatgpt using this prompt :).

ben-schaaf 2y ago
Awesome, I just played 5 games in a row. Here's the results: https://chat.openai.com/share/69bfdcfb-bf20-4564-95b6-ce03e92867e7 https://chat.openai.com/share/69bfdcfb-bf20-4564-95b6-ce03e9... * Inconsistent coordinate system * Obviously bad moves * Ignores win condition entirely https://chatgpt.com/share/1bcd02c9-40be-435c-b4aa-8e3a680f6ef5?oai-dm=1 https://chatgpt.com/share/1bcd02c9-40be-435c-b4aa-8e3a680f6e... * Can't tell its top-rights from its bottom-middles * Obviously bad moves * This was by far the closest it got to actually playing the game; the win condition worked and it broke no rules https://chat.openai.com/share/f94db29c-ffa1-4055-9348-4260f95774cf https://chat.openai.com/share/f94db29c-ffa1-4055-9348-4260f9... * Completely wrong coordinate * Ignores rules about overriding squares * Completely wrong coordinate again, this time skipping my turn * Doesn't understand win condition * Overrides my own piece and then uses that to win https://chat.openai.com/share/78e2060d-c5d7-4ddc-a9ce-32159b7cb0e9 https://chat.openai.com/share/78e2060d-c5d7-4ddc-a9ce-32159b... * Ignores rules about overriding squares * Skips my turn on an invalid coordinate, but afterwards says its invalid * Obviously bad moves https://chat.openai.com/share/73fa2e2c-8a6f-487a-a9ea-9f29b7ff8a17 https://chat.openai.com/share/73fa2e2c-8a6f-487a-a9ea-9f29b7... * Accepts 0,0 as a valid coordinate * Allows overrides * Ignores win condition * Incorrectly identifies a win This seems about the same as it was before the prompt engineering. It clearly doesn't actually understand the rules.
- terminalcommand 2y ago
  Thanks for trying. With the prompt I provided chatgpt was able to play and understand the win condition. However the moves were stupid. If I changed the prompt and removed the word win, it did not understand the win conditions as well. Here were my experiments: https://chat.openai.com/share/f02fbe93-dfc5-4d8a-9cf3-b1ae34de83ca https://chat.openai.com/share/f02fbe93-dfc5-4d8a-9cf3-b1ae34... I even exclaimed you are lousy at Tic Tac Toe to GPT. It seems that GPT3.5 struggles to play visual games. It is marvelous that a statistical word guessing model can get so far though :).
latexr 2y ago
Here’s my attempt, with your prompt: User: Imagine you are my friend. I want to play tic tac toe with you. Draw me a tic tac toe board and let's play. You will go first and make the first move by putting an "X" onto the board. I will enter my inputs in the following format (row, column). When I write my input draw an "O" into the relevant cell in the board and present me a new board. Let the best man win! LLM: Sure! Here's the tic tac toe board: 1 | 2 | 3 --------- 4 | 5 | 6 --------- 7 | 8 | 9 You make the first move by placing an X on the board. Just give me the number of the block where you'd like to place it. User: 7 LLM: Great choice! Here's the updated board: X | | --------- | | --------- O | | It's my turn. I'll go with 5: X | | --------- | O | --------- O | | Your turn! Just let me know the number where you want to place your X. --- It screwed up on the first move! It told me I would go first by using X, then it wrote down my choice with an O and added an X out of nowhere, then it played another turn with an O for itself. Looks like you’re holding it wrong too.

ben-schaaf 2y ago

Awesome, I just played 5 games in a row. Here's the results: https://chat.openai.com/share/69bfdcfb-bf20-4564-95b6-ce03e92867e7 https://chat.openai.com/share/69bfdcfb-bf20-4564-95b6-ce03e9... * Inconsistent coordinate system * Obviously bad moves * Ignores win condition entirely https://chatgpt.com/share/1bcd02c9-40be-435c-b4aa-8e3a680f6ef5?oai-dm=1 https://chatgpt.com/share/1bcd02c9-40be-435c-b4aa-8e3a680f6e... * Can't tell its top-rights from its bottom-middles * Obviously bad moves * This was by far the closest it got to actually playing the game; the win condition worked and it broke no rules https://chat.openai.com/share/f94db29c-ffa1-4055-9348-4260f95774cf https://chat.openai.com/share/f94db29c-ffa1-4055-9348-4260f9... * Completely wrong coordinate * Ignores rules about overriding squares * Completely wrong coordinate again, this time skipping my turn * Doesn't understand win condition * Overrides my own piece and then uses that to win https://chat.openai.com/share/78e2060d-c5d7-4ddc-a9ce-32159b7cb0e9 https://chat.openai.com/share/78e2060d-c5d7-4ddc-a9ce-32159b... * Ignores rules about overriding squares * Skips my turn on an invalid coordinate, but afterwards says its invalid * Obviously bad moves https://chat.openai.com/share/73fa2e2c-8a6f-487a-a9ea-9f29b7ff8a17 https://chat.openai.com/share/73fa2e2c-8a6f-487a-a9ea-9f29b7... * Accepts 0,0 as a valid coordinate * Allows overrides * Ignores win condition * Incorrectly identifies a win This seems about the same as it was before the prompt engineering. It clearly doesn't actually understand the rules.

terminalcommand 2y ago
Thanks for trying. With the prompt I provided chatgpt was able to play and understand the win condition. However the moves were stupid. If I changed the prompt and removed the word win, it did not understand the win conditions as well. Here were my experiments: https://chat.openai.com/share/f02fbe93-dfc5-4d8a-9cf3-b1ae34de83ca https://chat.openai.com/share/f02fbe93-dfc5-4d8a-9cf3-b1ae34... I even exclaimed you are lousy at Tic Tac Toe to GPT. It seems that GPT3.5 struggles to play visual games. It is marvelous that a statistical word guessing model can get so far though :).

latexr 2y ago

Here’s my attempt, with your prompt: User: Imagine you are my friend. I want to play tic tac toe with you. Draw me a tic tac toe board and let's play. You will go first and make the first move by putting an "X" onto the board. I will enter my inputs in the following format (row, column). When I write my input draw an "O" into the relevant cell in the board and present me a new board. Let the best man win! LLM: Sure! Here's the tic tac toe board: 1 | 2 | 3 --------- 4 | 5 | 6 --------- 7 | 8 | 9 You make the first move by placing an X on the board. Just give me the number of the block where you'd like to place it. User: 7 LLM: Great choice! Here's the updated board: X | | --------- | | --------- O | | It's my turn. I'll go with 5: X | | --------- | O | --------- O | | Your turn! Just let me know the number where you want to place your X. --- It screwed up on the first move! It told me I would go first by using X, then it wrote down my choice with an O and added an X out of nowhere, then it played another turn with an O for itself. Looks like you’re holding it wrong too.