5 ms·

The vast majority of arbitrage of fungible assets happens in commodities, not securities. The SEC regulates securities. The CFTC regulates commodities.

jprete 2y ago
Ok, but these are clearly not commodities.
- shemnon42 2y ago
  Clearly? What distinguishes them from beanie babies or used concert ticket stubs?
- siftrics 2y ago
  Why not? It is highly litigated and still abundantly unclear whether certain cryptocurrencies are securities or commodities. That's the whole point of these legal battles. If it was clear, they would not be ongoing.
  - pie420 2y ago
    based on the definition of what a security and what a commodity, it should be abundantly clear to anyone over the age of 5 what crypto falls under: Commodities are consumable goods that get transformed through usage in industrial or commercial processes. Gold and silver can be transformed into jewelry. Securities, on the other hand, grant holders the right to periodic benefits like dividends, coupons, principal repayments and potential profit shares. How are you consuming crypto? What commercial or industrial process are being used?
    - oarsinsync 2y ago
      > Commodities are consumable goods that get transformed through usage in industrial or commercial processes. Gold and silver can be transformed into jewelry. Securities, on the other hand, grant holders the right to periodic benefits like dividends, coupons, principal repayments and potential profit shares. > How are you consuming crypto? What commercial or industrial process are being used? What rights does holding bitcoin confer to the holder? I get no dividends, coupons, principle repayments or potential profit shares. We’ve nicely entered why this argument still rages on. It doesn’t fit cleanly into either definition.
- ikmckenz 2y ago
  From the CFTC: > Bitcoin is considered a commodity and is the underlying asset in bitcoin futures contracts… Bitcoin futures contracts — like other commodity futures contracts such as corn futures, market index futures, or gold futures — are regulated by the CFTC and must trade on CFTC-regulated exchanges. https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/BitcoinFuturesETF.html https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/B...
  - jprete 2y ago
    Thanks for the reference. Between this, megadal's sibling-comment Wikipedia quote, and a quick search of "economic good", I believe I was mistaken.
- SkyPuncher 2y ago
  10 years ago, I’d probably agree with you. Today, you can spin up your own shit coin with basically a few clicks.
  - megadal 2y ago
    The fact that you can create a crypto more easily today has nothing to do with whether or not crypto is a commodity (though I suspect that point is not really why you made this comment). It's the fact that there's an overwhelming number of exchanges that willingly accept crypto from other exchanges coupled with the fact that anyone can mine/produce crypto. The moment that there were two places to get BTC that accept BTC from each other in exchange for money, it was a commodity.
- megadal 2y ago
  From Wikipedia: > In economics, a commodity is an economic good, usually a resource, that specifically has full or substantial fungibility: that is, the market treats instances of the good as equivalent or nearly so with no regard to who produced them. I am pretty sure you can get BTC from any exchange and sell it on any other exchange. Whereas, with stocks, you generally cannot as a retail investor. That is, I suppose, what makes crypto a commodity at its core.
ajross 2y ago
> The vast majority of arbitrage of fungible assets happens in commodities, not securities. Yeah, I'm gonna say no to that. I don't have numbers but if total trading volume on commodities is anything more than a tiny fraction of stock/derivatives trading on any given day I eat my proverbial hat. Regardless, "The CFTC needs to sue us, not the SEC" isn't the argument being made by Robinhood either.
- siftrics 2y ago
  Derivatives are governed by the CFTC not the SEC. It does matter, because they aren't doing anything wrong if these crypto assets are considered commodities and not securities. Also, just because a government agency is suing you, that doesn't mean it has any legal or moral imperative. I don't see your point.
  - ajross 2y ago
    Again, that's wrong. The CFTC absolutely does not handle regulation of options and bond funds and ETFs, etc... You seem to be invoking this "commodities" thing as a trick, and that's not how it works. We've seen this repeatably now where the SEC has to come at crypto outfits with a cluebat and explain to them (in court!) that yes: crypto assets are securities. Why do you really think it's going to be different this time?
    - siftrics 2y ago
      From the CFTC's official website: "The Commodity Futures Trading Commission is an independent U.S. government agency that regulates the U.S. derivatives markets, including futures, options, and swaps." Also from their official website: 20 quadrillion per week in settled trades. Too lazy to look up the equities numbers, but I would bet everything I own it's lower. Also from the CFTC's website: "Bitcoin is considered a commodity and is the underlying asset in bitcoin futures contracts… Bitcoin futures contracts — like other commodity futures contracts such as corn futures, market index futures, or gold futures — are regulated by the CFTC and must trade on CFTC-regulated exchanges."

jprete 2y ago

Ok, but these are clearly not commodities.

shemnon42 2y ago
Clearly? What distinguishes them from beanie babies or used concert ticket stubs?
siftrics 2y ago
Why not? It is highly litigated and still abundantly unclear whether certain cryptocurrencies are securities or commodities. That's the whole point of these legal battles. If it was clear, they would not be ongoing.
- pie420 2y ago
  based on the definition of what a security and what a commodity, it should be abundantly clear to anyone over the age of 5 what crypto falls under: Commodities are consumable goods that get transformed through usage in industrial or commercial processes. Gold and silver can be transformed into jewelry. Securities, on the other hand, grant holders the right to periodic benefits like dividends, coupons, principal repayments and potential profit shares. How are you consuming crypto? What commercial or industrial process are being used?
  - oarsinsync 2y ago
    > Commodities are consumable goods that get transformed through usage in industrial or commercial processes. Gold and silver can be transformed into jewelry. Securities, on the other hand, grant holders the right to periodic benefits like dividends, coupons, principal repayments and potential profit shares. > How are you consuming crypto? What commercial or industrial process are being used? What rights does holding bitcoin confer to the holder? I get no dividends, coupons, principle repayments or potential profit shares. We’ve nicely entered why this argument still rages on. It doesn’t fit cleanly into either definition.
ikmckenz 2y ago
From the CFTC: > Bitcoin is considered a commodity and is the underlying asset in bitcoin futures contracts… Bitcoin futures contracts — like other commodity futures contracts such as corn futures, market index futures, or gold futures — are regulated by the CFTC and must trade on CFTC-regulated exchanges. https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/BitcoinFuturesETF.html https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/B...
- jprete 2y ago
  Thanks for the reference. Between this, megadal's sibling-comment Wikipedia quote, and a quick search of "economic good", I believe I was mistaken.
SkyPuncher 2y ago
10 years ago, I’d probably agree with you. Today, you can spin up your own shit coin with basically a few clicks.
- megadal 2y ago
  The fact that you can create a crypto more easily today has nothing to do with whether or not crypto is a commodity (though I suspect that point is not really why you made this comment). It's the fact that there's an overwhelming number of exchanges that willingly accept crypto from other exchanges coupled with the fact that anyone can mine/produce crypto. The moment that there were two places to get BTC that accept BTC from each other in exchange for money, it was a commodity.
megadal 2y ago
From Wikipedia: > In economics, a commodity is an economic good, usually a resource, that specifically has full or substantial fungibility: that is, the market treats instances of the good as equivalent or nearly so with no regard to who produced them. I am pretty sure you can get BTC from any exchange and sell it on any other exchange. Whereas, with stocks, you generally cannot as a retail investor. That is, I suppose, what makes crypto a commodity at its core.

ajross 2y ago

> The vast majority of arbitrage of fungible assets happens in commodities, not securities. Yeah, I'm gonna say no to that. I don't have numbers but if total trading volume on commodities is anything more than a tiny fraction of stock/derivatives trading on any given day I eat my proverbial hat. Regardless, "The CFTC needs to sue us, not the SEC" isn't the argument being made by Robinhood either.

siftrics 2y ago
Derivatives are governed by the CFTC not the SEC. It does matter, because they aren't doing anything wrong if these crypto assets are considered commodities and not securities. Also, just because a government agency is suing you, that doesn't mean it has any legal or moral imperative. I don't see your point.
- ajross 2y ago
  Again, that's wrong. The CFTC absolutely does not handle regulation of options and bond funds and ETFs, etc... You seem to be invoking this "commodities" thing as a trick, and that's not how it works. We've seen this repeatably now where the SEC has to come at crypto outfits with a cluebat and explain to them (in court!) that yes: crypto assets are securities. Why do you really think it's going to be different this time?
  - siftrics 2y ago
    From the CFTC's official website: "The Commodity Futures Trading Commission is an independent U.S. government agency that regulates the U.S. derivatives markets, including futures, options, and swaps." Also from their official website: 20 quadrillion per week in settled trades. Too lazy to look up the equities numbers, but I would bet everything I own it's lower. Also from the CFTC's website: "Bitcoin is considered a commodity and is the underlying asset in bitcoin futures contracts… Bitcoin futures contracts — like other commodity futures contracts such as corn futures, market index futures, or gold futures — are regulated by the CFTC and must trade on CFTC-regulated exchanges."