5 ms·

> You are still dependent on foreign inputs that are dependent on the Dollar or Yuan payments For Russia in particular, do we have some idea of how true this a

> You are still dependent on foreign inputs that are dependent on the Dollar or Yuan payments For Russia in particular, do we have some idea of how true this actually is? Russia lacks a lot of things, but natural resources is generally not one of them.

alephnerd 2y ago
> For Russia in particular, do we have some idea of how true this actually is? Russia lacks a lot of things, but natural resources is generally not one of them. This isn't a game of Civ 4 where access to resources automatically grants you production. For example, the Oktyabrsky Mine is one of the largest nickel mines in the world, yet Russia has to export that nickel abroad to be processed in order to be used in batteries or integrated circuits. And resources are not interchangeable - oil from Dharan has an entirely different set of specs to process compared to oil from northern Alberta. Resources aren't that rare - most countries just choose not to exploit resources because they might not be an efficient deployment of capital (why should I spend billions subsidizing a commodity product whose margins are near 0 or even negative when I can use that money to build a hospital instead) There's a reason people get PhDs in Chemical Engineering, Chemistry, Geology, Mining Engineering, Physics, Geophysics, Petroleum Engineering, etc - these are very complex and specialized problems, and no country has a complete monopoly on human capital in these spaces. Moments like this make me wish HN was shut down - it's gotten so braindead.
- sapiogram 2y ago
  Thank you for your response. I think your final remark was unnecessary though, I think less people asking stupid questions just leads to more confidently incorrect non-questions, which is not an improvement.
  - alephnerd 2y ago
    Just a bit burned out by the low quality non-technical discourse on HN as someone who actually used to work in the Policy space. I use HN to read articles or comments about ld_preload or shoot the shit about internal gossip in the tech industry - not rehash the same kinds of arguments you see on Reddit. > I think less people asking stupid questions just leads to more confidently incorrect non-questions Until domain experts get burned out and start flamewars for shits and giggles, or just quit HN entirely.
    - notact 2y ago
      sapiogram made no assertions or arguments, just asked a simple, reasonable and good-faith question. Your response was disproportionately negative.
- imtringued 2y ago
  Yeah the comments by alephnerd really drag this place down. "Please don't post comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills." I hope you've seen that rule.
  - alephnerd 2y ago
    I absolutely have seen that rule and I will continue to yell this at the clouds in the sky - DISCOURSE ON HN HAS ABSOLUTELY DEGRADED.

alephnerd 2y ago

> For Russia in particular, do we have some idea of how true this actually is? Russia lacks a lot of things, but natural resources is generally not one of them. This isn't a game of Civ 4 where access to resources automatically grants you production. For example, the Oktyabrsky Mine is one of the largest nickel mines in the world, yet Russia has to export that nickel abroad to be processed in order to be used in batteries or integrated circuits. And resources are not interchangeable - oil from Dharan has an entirely different set of specs to process compared to oil from northern Alberta. Resources aren't that rare - most countries just choose not to exploit resources because they might not be an efficient deployment of capital (why should I spend billions subsidizing a commodity product whose margins are near 0 or even negative when I can use that money to build a hospital instead) There's a reason people get PhDs in Chemical Engineering, Chemistry, Geology, Mining Engineering, Physics, Geophysics, Petroleum Engineering, etc - these are very complex and specialized problems, and no country has a complete monopoly on human capital in these spaces. Moments like this make me wish HN was shut down - it's gotten so braindead.

sapiogram 2y ago
Thank you for your response. I think your final remark was unnecessary though, I think less people asking stupid questions just leads to more confidently incorrect non-questions, which is not an improvement.
- alephnerd 2y ago
  Just a bit burned out by the low quality non-technical discourse on HN as someone who actually used to work in the Policy space. I use HN to read articles or comments about ld_preload or shoot the shit about internal gossip in the tech industry - not rehash the same kinds of arguments you see on Reddit. > I think less people asking stupid questions just leads to more confidently incorrect non-questions Until domain experts get burned out and start flamewars for shits and giggles, or just quit HN entirely.
  - notact 2y ago
    sapiogram made no assertions or arguments, just asked a simple, reasonable and good-faith question. Your response was disproportionately negative.
imtringued 2y ago
Yeah the comments by alephnerd really drag this place down. "Please don't post comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills." I hope you've seen that rule.
- alephnerd 2y ago
  I absolutely have seen that rule and I will continue to yell this at the clouds in the sky - DISCOURSE ON HN HAS ABSOLUTELY DEGRADED.