8 ms·
Peer review goes beyond simple issues about clarity or misunderstanding. In particular, peer review is sometimes seen as an adversarial process. Often, the rev
by Muller20 2y ago
Peer review goes beyond simple issues about clarity or misunderstanding. In particular, peer review is sometimes seen as an adversarial process.
Often, the reviewer will not understand because he is not the intended audience. Other times, he will understand but he just doesn't like your method, because he is working in an opposite direction. Or maybe your method is a direct competitor of his and yours work better, which incentivizes some people to block your work.
- wrycoder 2y agoOr your paper goes against the current paradigm or is otherwise politically unpalatable.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anticensor 2y ago> Other times, he will understand but he just doesn't like your method, because he is working in an opposite direction. Or maybe your method is a direct competitor of his and yours work better, which incentivizes some people to block your work. Oh you mean those phantom "off topic"/"out of scope" reviews.