8 ms·
> This is a personal project aiming to replicate analog coupling dynamics with asynchronous digital circuits FPGAs, not a claim that we can solve NP complete pr
by fpgamlirfanboy 2y ago
> This is a personal project aiming to replicate analog coupling dynamics with asynchronous digital circuits FPGAs, not a claim that we can solve NP complete problems with a fundamental speedup.
Then you shouldn't have led with that? It's like academic clickbait to say "here's this thing I'm working on, it uses XYZ technique to solve REALLY HARD PROBLEM" but omit the "...very poorly" part. Like I said I don't entirely blame you, I blame the academics that have an entire cottage industry and culture around these kinds of "results".
> These sorts of Ising architectures get their speed-up are based on oscillator interaction, not parallelism.
Not sure what you're trying to say - it's quantum annealing "brought to life" using simple 2-state (up/down) particles/phonos/whatever you want to call them. The quantum in quantum annealing means superposition ie parallelism; your implementation is basically a D-Wave machine without the qubits.
- zachbee 2y agoI dunno man, I think saying "this is a personal project of mine" and linking to an open source github repo implies that it's a casual side project. I never made any performance claims, it's just for fun. I'm not trying to put up clickbait. And yeah, I think the fact that you can build a classical, analog, D-Wave-sans-qubits machine on an FPGA is cool!