5 ms·

I think you may be confusing naturopathic with homeopathic. Naturopathic medicine use natureceuticals/supplements all the time. These contain active ingredient

I think you may be confusing naturopathic with homeopathic. Naturopathic medicine use natureceuticals/supplements all the time. These contain active ingredients in usable dosages that have research about their mechanism of actions and many of them work quite well. (Witch Hazel may be one! Vitamins and minerals are also common. Fish oil too.) Homeopathy is a specific belief in homeopathic remedies, which as described in the article are pretty thoroughly debunked pseudoscience. They dilute things down, but the effects are no different than placebo. In my opinion, this is a really unfortunate confusion that a lot of people have. Natural supplements are useful, and when they are proven useful, they often get turned into regulated medicines! However, homeopathic remedies are entirely different and get to 'free-ride' on the confusion created in the alternative health industry.

winternett 3y ago
I never presented myself as a medical professional of any sort. I think you're getting too hung up on semantics rather than reading what I typed.
- navjack27 3y ago
  The semantics mean a great deal. It's not getting hung up, it's saying two entirely different things.
- amazonslave 3y ago
  No, I did read what you typed. You are confusing terms and honestly most people do it (which was the point of my post). This Witch Hazel product at CVS is not homeopathic.[1] This is a normal Witch Hazel supplement that is pure distilled Witch Hazel. This is not homeopathic. Most people think 'homeopathic' just means 'natural supplements/alternative medicines'. That IS NOT what it is. Homeopathy is a specific 'ritual' that is done where the compound that 'causes illness' is diluted many, many, many times until there is effectively none of it left in the bottle. It is psuedoscience AND IT IS NOT NATURAL MEDICINE. [2] It matters to understand this, because the homeopathic industry obviously uses this confusion to their advantage. [1] https://www.cvs.com/shop/t-n-dickinson-s-witch-hazel-all-natural-astringent-prodid-1030507?skuId=108852 https://www.cvs.com/shop/t-n-dickinson-s-witch-hazel-all-nat... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy

winternett 3y ago

I never presented myself as a medical professional of any sort. I think you're getting too hung up on semantics rather than reading what I typed.

navjack27 3y ago
The semantics mean a great deal. It's not getting hung up, it's saying two entirely different things.
amazonslave 3y ago
No, I did read what you typed. You are confusing terms and honestly most people do it (which was the point of my post). This Witch Hazel product at CVS is not homeopathic.[1] This is a normal Witch Hazel supplement that is pure distilled Witch Hazel. This is not homeopathic. Most people think 'homeopathic' just means 'natural supplements/alternative medicines'. That IS NOT what it is. Homeopathy is a specific 'ritual' that is done where the compound that 'causes illness' is diluted many, many, many times until there is effectively none of it left in the bottle. It is psuedoscience AND IT IS NOT NATURAL MEDICINE. [2] It matters to understand this, because the homeopathic industry obviously uses this confusion to their advantage. [1] https://www.cvs.com/shop/t-n-dickinson-s-witch-hazel-all-natural-astringent-prodid-1030507?skuId=108852 https://www.cvs.com/shop/t-n-dickinson-s-witch-hazel-all-nat... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy