6 ms·
So basically a multi-person Zettelkasten? The idea with a Zettelkasten (zk for short) is that each note is a singular idea, concept, or argument that is all lin
by tomodachi94 3y ago
So basically a multi-person Zettelkasten? The idea with a Zettelkasten (zk for short) is that each note is a singular idea, concept, or argument that is all linked together. Arguments can link to their evidence, concepts can link to other related concepts, and so on.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zettelkasten https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zettelkasten
- tunesmith 3y agoSort of except that it also tracks truth propagation - one person disagreeing would inform others that portion of the graph is contested. So the graph has behavior. And, the links have logical meaning, beyond just "is related to" - it respects boolean logic. You can see some of the explanation at http://concludia.org/instructions http://concludia.org/instructions .
- couchand 3y ago> it respects boolean logic. Intuitionist or classical?
- tunesmith 3y agoIntuitionist. Truth is provability; the propagation model is basically digital logic. If you mark a premise to a conclusion false, the conclusion is then marked "false" but it really just means "it is false that it is proven"; vitiated. Might still be true, just needs further work.
- quickthrower2 3y agoYou would need a highly disciplined and motivated set of people in the team. I have been on courses where teams do this on pen/paper and it is a real skill and it is all you do for days. Forget anything else like programming, finishing work, etc.
- xpe 3y agoI'd be stoked if you wrote more about this experience and shared it somewhere.
- gitgud 3y agoIsn’t this what Wikipedia is in essence? Ideas, concepts linked together, with supporting evidence