8 ms·

> You mean like all of the developers who aren’t creating native apps on Android and are creating PWAs? I'm not sure I understand your wording right... Are you

> You mean like all of the developers who aren’t creating native apps on Android and are creating PWAs? I'm not sure I understand your wording right... Are you saying that devs creating PWAs are "free?" Because it's well-known that PWAs has been stunted by Apple and Google. The technology is well behind its potential. PWAs could do significantly more if they had better access to system APIs.

scarface74 4y ago
So now there is a great conspiracy by both Apple and Google? Maybe web technologies just aren’t as good as native? In the history of computing there has never been a cross platform general purpose GUI framework that didn’t suck. Not to mention most Android devices in the wild are low end and don’t handle complex web pages well
- arcturus17 4y ago
  > So now there is a great conspiracy by both Apple and Google? What conspiracy? They have huge economic disincentives to further PWAs - there is no need for any conspiracy. In the first presentation of the iPhone, Steve Jobs laid out a vision where the smartphone would run web apps, using fundamental web technologies (HTML, CSS, JS). He quickly backtracked when he realised Apple could impose a 30% tax on transactions in the platform. > Maybe web technologies just aren’t as good as native? No one said they are, but that's no excuse to drag your feet in implementing simple things like push notifications. > In the history of computing there has never been a cross platform general purpose GUI framework that didn’t suck. What GUI framework? I barely even know what we are talking about anymore. You don't need one with PWA - again, you're using fundamental web technologies, and enabling them to make system calls. > Not to mention most Android devices in the wild are low end and don’t handle complex web pages well So that's another excuse to not further PWAs, huh?
  - scarface74 4y ago
    > What GUI framework? I barely even know what we are talking about anymore. You don't need one with PWA - again, you're using fundamental web technologies, and enabling them to make system calls. Let me ask you this then. Name one cross platform framework that wasn’t meant to build command line tools that hasn’t sucked? QT? Java Spring? React Native? Electron? > In the first presentation of the iPhone, Steve Jobs laid out a vision where the smartphone would run web apps, using fundamental web technologies (HTML, CSS, JS). He quickly backtracked when he realised Apple could impose a 30% tax on transactions in the platform. He “backtracked” because his “sweet solution” wasn’t good and everyone wanted native apps and web apps were called “a shit sandwich” by developers. Do you know the history of creating “applications” using “web technologies”? They failed for RIM, Microsoft, and Palm. Web apps suck not to mention the clusterfuck of the front end ecosystem. Every single platform that went down the “we can do great web apps” backtracked. They have never been good enough. > So that's another excuse to not further PWAs, huh? You mean making an app that’s actually performant on the majority of phones out there?
    - arcturus17 4y ago
      > He “backtracked” because his “sweet solution” wasn’t good and everyone wanted native apps and web apps were called “a shit sandwich” by developers. Sure, the 30% cut of all sales was just a sweet coincidence. > You mean making an app that’s actually performant on the majority of phones out there? Twitter and Uber have PWAs for countries where low-end devices are the majority of phones. > They have never been good enough. Complete bollocks, there are plenty of excellent web apps out there, and it's one of the most important mechanisms for software delivery nowadays, in both the enterprise and consumer spaces. You are a fundamentalist and there is no point discussing anything here anymore
      - scarface74 4y ago
        Were you around back then when developers were clamoring for native apps? It came out in the Epic trial that 80% of all app revenue came from games with in app purchases. Besides that, most of the biggest players like Netflix and Spotify don’t even allow in app purchases. Where are all of the great web apps for mobile? Have you tried using any of these web apps on Firefox for Android or is Firefox also involved in the conspiracy? No one is clamoring for cross platform web apps accept web developers who want to foster a shitty Electron like experience on mobile. And look at all of the server side work that Uber had to do. https://www.uber.com/blog/m-uber/ https://www.uber.com/blog/m-uber/ And this wasn’t done to avoid the “30% tax” since Uber doesn’t use in app purchases. You do have Apple Pay as an option. But that’s a standard credit card transaction.
madeofpalk 4y ago
> Because it's well-known that PWAs has been stunted by Apple and Google. It is not well-known. It is well-believed. I don't believe Apple has intentionally crippled Safari just to prop up their native platform. Google are the ones who invented the PWA buzzword and spend all their devrel effort on pushing. It's hard to believe they would also try and hamper that.
- beefield 4y ago
  I have occasionally needed to advise mobile users how to use a simple web app showing phone's location on a map. Sample size is at least tens of people, selection bias to somewhat young and active people. Based on this "research",for a median iPhone user a location-aware web app is simply broken. Without external help, they are unable to change the (default/dark pattern, I do not know?) setting of not letting browser access to location data. You are welcome to come up with reasons why Apple has made it so difficult. I have difficulties to think other than intentionally crippling web apps.
  - scarface74 4y ago
    The browser asks for the same permission for location access as any other app does. Once you deny it access, you have to go into settings to change it - just like any other app. How much money do you think Apple makes when the same probably free website is a free app?
  - TylerE 4y ago
    That certainly isn’t the default.
  - vuln 4y ago
    Privacy? Not every website I visit needs to know my location. Not every website with a map needs access to my location. Only websites I specifically allow to access my location should have access. On the iPhone and specifically safari I've never had an issue or a steep learning curve to showing someone how to long press the reader view (AA) in the url then select _allow location_ or whatever. I wonder if you sample all had something in common. Did they not regularly use this web app? Was this an event specific web app? If so it would be nice if the web app detected mobile browser by user agent and displayed instructions for activating location. Might help reduce confusion.
wolfendin 4y ago
They might be able to do more but that isn’t going to make them better. Just look at how reviled Electron is compared to native applications.
- pier25 4y ago
  The problem with Electron is that it's bloated by including a full browser engine and Node. A couple of years ago I worked on an app that ran on 5 platforms (iOS, Android, Windows, macOS, ChromeOS). Initially we used Phonegap and Electron but then we created our own native wrapper that used the OS webview. Our macOS app went from 100MB to 5MB of download size and the memory usage also went down considerably. IIRC correctly it consumed like 15MB of memory. It certainly didn't look native but for our use case (education) that was not an issue. We were able to target 5 platforms with a very small team and the GUI was a single codebase made with InfernoJS and MobX.
  - pipeline_peak 4y ago
    Everyone loves to complain about how bloated Electron is. No one offers a solution that performs as well in supporting all of modern webs technologies.
    - scarface74 4y ago
      A better idea is not to use “web technologies” to create a native app
      - pipeline_peak 4y ago
        The tech industry begs to differ
        scarface74 4y ago
        Google moved away from cross platform frameworks - including its own. https://9to5google.com/2021/10/10/google-ios-apps-native/ https://9to5google.com/2021/10/10/google-ios-apps-native/ Facebook moved away from cross platform web based frameworks for its apps years ago. Microsoft’s mobile and desktop apps (besides Teams which also sucks and VSCode which is pretty good) are not using web frameworks.
p1necone 4y ago
> PWAs could do significantly more if they had better access to system APIs. Isn't the whole point of PWAs that they're easy because they're just web apps? If you start using system/OS specific APIs you lose all of the benefits except for the instant install time.

scarface74 4y ago

So now there is a great conspiracy by both Apple and Google? Maybe web technologies just aren’t as good as native? In the history of computing there has never been a cross platform general purpose GUI framework that didn’t suck. Not to mention most Android devices in the wild are low end and don’t handle complex web pages well

arcturus17 4y ago
> So now there is a great conspiracy by both Apple and Google? What conspiracy? They have huge economic disincentives to further PWAs - there is no need for any conspiracy. In the first presentation of the iPhone, Steve Jobs laid out a vision where the smartphone would run web apps, using fundamental web technologies (HTML, CSS, JS). He quickly backtracked when he realised Apple could impose a 30% tax on transactions in the platform. > Maybe web technologies just aren’t as good as native? No one said they are, but that's no excuse to drag your feet in implementing simple things like push notifications. > In the history of computing there has never been a cross platform general purpose GUI framework that didn’t suck. What GUI framework? I barely even know what we are talking about anymore. You don't need one with PWA - again, you're using fundamental web technologies, and enabling them to make system calls. > Not to mention most Android devices in the wild are low end and don’t handle complex web pages well So that's another excuse to not further PWAs, huh?
- scarface74 4y ago
  > What GUI framework? I barely even know what we are talking about anymore. You don't need one with PWA - again, you're using fundamental web technologies, and enabling them to make system calls. Let me ask you this then. Name one cross platform framework that wasn’t meant to build command line tools that hasn’t sucked? QT? Java Spring? React Native? Electron? > In the first presentation of the iPhone, Steve Jobs laid out a vision where the smartphone would run web apps, using fundamental web technologies (HTML, CSS, JS). He quickly backtracked when he realised Apple could impose a 30% tax on transactions in the platform. He “backtracked” because his “sweet solution” wasn’t good and everyone wanted native apps and web apps were called “a shit sandwich” by developers. Do you know the history of creating “applications” using “web technologies”? They failed for RIM, Microsoft, and Palm. Web apps suck not to mention the clusterfuck of the front end ecosystem. Every single platform that went down the “we can do great web apps” backtracked. They have never been good enough. > So that's another excuse to not further PWAs, huh? You mean making an app that’s actually performant on the majority of phones out there?
  - arcturus17 4y ago
    > He “backtracked” because his “sweet solution” wasn’t good and everyone wanted native apps and web apps were called “a shit sandwich” by developers. Sure, the 30% cut of all sales was just a sweet coincidence. > You mean making an app that’s actually performant on the majority of phones out there? Twitter and Uber have PWAs for countries where low-end devices are the majority of phones. > They have never been good enough. Complete bollocks, there are plenty of excellent web apps out there, and it's one of the most important mechanisms for software delivery nowadays, in both the enterprise and consumer spaces. You are a fundamentalist and there is no point discussing anything here anymore
    - scarface74 4y ago
      Were you around back then when developers were clamoring for native apps? It came out in the Epic trial that 80% of all app revenue came from games with in app purchases. Besides that, most of the biggest players like Netflix and Spotify don’t even allow in app purchases. Where are all of the great web apps for mobile? Have you tried using any of these web apps on Firefox for Android or is Firefox also involved in the conspiracy? No one is clamoring for cross platform web apps accept web developers who want to foster a shitty Electron like experience on mobile. And look at all of the server side work that Uber had to do. https://www.uber.com/blog/m-uber/ https://www.uber.com/blog/m-uber/ And this wasn’t done to avoid the “30% tax” since Uber doesn’t use in app purchases. You do have Apple Pay as an option. But that’s a standard credit card transaction.

madeofpalk 4y ago

> Because it's well-known that PWAs has been stunted by Apple and Google. It is not well-known. It is well-believed. I don't believe Apple has intentionally crippled Safari just to prop up their native platform. Google are the ones who invented the PWA buzzword and spend all their devrel effort on pushing. It's hard to believe they would also try and hamper that.

beefield 4y ago
I have occasionally needed to advise mobile users how to use a simple web app showing phone's location on a map. Sample size is at least tens of people, selection bias to somewhat young and active people. Based on this "research",for a median iPhone user a location-aware web app is simply broken. Without external help, they are unable to change the (default/dark pattern, I do not know?) setting of not letting browser access to location data. You are welcome to come up with reasons why Apple has made it so difficult. I have difficulties to think other than intentionally crippling web apps.
- scarface74 4y ago
  The browser asks for the same permission for location access as any other app does. Once you deny it access, you have to go into settings to change it - just like any other app. How much money do you think Apple makes when the same probably free website is a free app?
- TylerE 4y ago
  That certainly isn’t the default.
- vuln 4y ago
  Privacy? Not every website I visit needs to know my location. Not every website with a map needs access to my location. Only websites I specifically allow to access my location should have access. On the iPhone and specifically safari I've never had an issue or a steep learning curve to showing someone how to long press the reader view (AA) in the url then select _allow location_ or whatever. I wonder if you sample all had something in common. Did they not regularly use this web app? Was this an event specific web app? If so it would be nice if the web app detected mobile browser by user agent and displayed instructions for activating location. Might help reduce confusion.

wolfendin 4y ago

They might be able to do more but that isn’t going to make them better. Just look at how reviled Electron is compared to native applications.

pier25 4y ago
The problem with Electron is that it's bloated by including a full browser engine and Node. A couple of years ago I worked on an app that ran on 5 platforms (iOS, Android, Windows, macOS, ChromeOS). Initially we used Phonegap and Electron but then we created our own native wrapper that used the OS webview. Our macOS app went from 100MB to 5MB of download size and the memory usage also went down considerably. IIRC correctly it consumed like 15MB of memory. It certainly didn't look native but for our use case (education) that was not an issue. We were able to target 5 platforms with a very small team and the GUI was a single codebase made with InfernoJS and MobX.
- pipeline_peak 4y ago
  Everyone loves to complain about how bloated Electron is. No one offers a solution that performs as well in supporting all of modern webs technologies.
  - scarface74 4y ago
    A better idea is not to use “web technologies” to create a native app
    - pipeline_peak 4y ago
      The tech industry begs to differ
      - scarface74 4y ago
        Google moved away from cross platform frameworks - including its own. https://9to5google.com/2021/10/10/google-ios-apps-native/ https://9to5google.com/2021/10/10/google-ios-apps-native/ Facebook moved away from cross platform web based frameworks for its apps years ago. Microsoft’s mobile and desktop apps (besides Teams which also sucks and VSCode which is pretty good) are not using web frameworks.

p1necone 4y ago

> PWAs could do significantly more if they had better access to system APIs. Isn't the whole point of PWAs that they're easy because they're just web apps? If you start using system/OS specific APIs you lose all of the benefits except for the instant install time.