Thought experiment: between you and the AI, which would do a better job depicting a giraffe skeleton? A giraffe in it's natural habitat? Their favorite tree to

Thought experiment: between you and the AI, which would do a better job depicting a giraffe skeleton? A giraffe in it's natural habitat? Their favorite tree to eat? Species on the genetic tree closest to giraffes? If we assume this AI or a successor can win that evaluation, in what way would you say you know what a giraffe is better than the AI?