5 ms·

Ask HN: What are some good reasons for reinventing the wheel?

8 points by joeclef 5y ago

In the context of industry software development, what are some good reasons for reinventing the wheels?

h2odragon 5y ago
To gain a better understanding of why the one that's there is designed as it is. Sometimes there's legacy crap in the previous design thats no longer needed, or you have better materials, and can make the new one more elegant and functional. Sometimes it just gives you the opportunity to see all the failure modes that weren't obvious until you stuck your paper wheel in the place where a steel one had been.
- RicoElectrico 5y ago
  This is one of the most common mistakes in software development: not appreciating that the true value of code is the knowledge embodied in it over time.
jstx1 5y ago
You want a different/nicer wheel and the cost of reinventing it is low enough to make it worth it.
vmoore 5y ago
If you're doing clean room design: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design then reinvention is allowed
beardyw 5y ago
If reinventing the wheel implies no added benefit, the answer is never (or perhaps for educational reasons as someone else has suggested). If you can identify a benefit, that needs to be weighed against the cost. A benefit may involve maintainability, flexibility, extendibility or any number of ibilities. But that is more like improving the wheel which is OK.
crate_barre 5y ago
I always say there’s only one rule you have to follow with respect to reinventing the wheel: Do it on your time, don’t bring that shit to work.
kello 5y ago
To learn
markus_zhang 5y ago
Ownership, chance to go back as consultant, chance to speak at conference. Unless you are an architect or/and an old man/woman or/and don't enjoy programming, I don't see any reason you don't want to reinvent the wheels.
toast0 5y ago
More control, different choices for tradeoffs, it's a decent way to get detailed knowledge, a reinvented wheel that only works for your specific company may be a better fit and simpler than a universal wheel. Of course, there's plenty of ways to waste a lot of resources reinventing the wheel.

8 points by joeclef 5y ago

In the context of industry software development, what are some good reasons for reinventing the wheels?

To gain a better understanding of why the one that's there is designed as it is. Sometimes there's legacy crap in the previous design thats no longer needed, or you have better materials, and can make the new one more elegant and functional. Sometimes it just gives you the opportunity to see all the failure modes that weren't obvious until you stuck your paper wheel in the place where a steel one had been.

RicoElectrico 5y ago
This is one of the most common mistakes in software development: not appreciating that the true value of code is the knowledge embodied in it over time.

jstx1 5y ago

You want a different/nicer wheel and the cost of reinventing it is low enough to make it worth it.

vmoore 5y ago

If you're doing clean room design: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design then reinvention is allowed

beardyw 5y ago

If reinventing the wheel implies no added benefit, the answer is never (or perhaps for educational reasons as someone else has suggested). If you can identify a benefit, that needs to be weighed against the cost. A benefit may involve maintainability, flexibility, extendibility or any number of ibilities. But that is more like improving the wheel which is OK.

crate_barre 5y ago

I always say there’s only one rule you have to follow with respect to reinventing the wheel: Do it on your time, don’t bring that shit to work.

kello 5y ago

To learn

markus_zhang 5y ago

Ownership, chance to go back as consultant, chance to speak at conference. Unless you are an architect or/and an old man/woman or/and don't enjoy programming, I don't see any reason you don't want to reinvent the wheels.

toast0 5y ago

More control, different choices for tradeoffs, it's a decent way to get detailed knowledge, a reinvented wheel that only works for your specific company may be a better fit and simpler than a universal wheel. Of course, there's plenty of ways to waste a lot of resources reinventing the wheel.