9 ms·

Doesn't ffmpeg provide similar functionality?

by boromi 5y ago

arbitrage 5y ago
brb reading man pages. again. in three different terminals. ffmpeg is a great tool, and time is well spent getting to know how to use it. but it takes a lot of time/effort to get there.
capableweb 5y ago
Well, yeah, both can be used for mostly the same things (probably ffmpeg has more features in total though), but ffmpeg doesn't have a GUI, which HandBrake does.
wfleming 5y ago
Yes, but Handbrake provides a GUI. Ffmpeg is fantastic, and I believe supports a wider range of formats than Handbrake, so it's the power user's tool of choice. But Handbrake is way more accessible for the average user, and is very high quality in its own way.
deleted 5y ago
[deleted]
merb 5y ago
ah the good old dropbox. > https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 just gold. btw. handbrake is simple to use, ffmpeg is not.
prvc 5y ago
Aside from the interface, Handbrake provides many features not implemented in ffmpeg, especially concerning extracting data from DVDs. Handbrake is also the easiest way for non-technical people to transcode videos from one format, resolution, or quality to another.
concinds 5y ago
I find ffmpeg more intuitive. Handbrake only has presets, and it pre-fills so many options for you. Why can't I just have "original" everything, just change the format? I don't want any changes except codec, but with Handbrake I don't feel confident it's not going beyond that.
- MattPalmer1086 5y ago
  I'm the same. I used to use handbrake, but found the presets didn't work very well. I set up custom presetsz fiddled with lots of things, and still failed to always get the right subtitles or audio or something. I've switched to ffmpeg now, with MakeMKV to do the rip. I find this works better and more reliably. It also let's me separate the ripping from the transcoding. So I can rip really fast and just queue up the transcoding.
cjensen 5y ago
Yes, and under the hood Handbrake is using the FFmpeg libraries. Handbrake's value is providing simple presets that "just work" for converting video for various uses. Want to convert video for playback on an iPhone? Handbrake has you covered.

Doesn't ffmpeg provide similar functionality?

by boromi 5y ago

Doesn't ffmpeg provide similar functionality?

brb reading man pages. again. in three different terminals. ffmpeg is a great tool, and time is well spent getting to know how to use it. but it takes a lot of time/effort to get there.

capableweb 5y ago

Well, yeah, both can be used for mostly the same things (probably ffmpeg has more features in total though), but ffmpeg doesn't have a GUI, which HandBrake does.

wfleming 5y ago

Yes, but Handbrake provides a GUI. Ffmpeg is fantastic, and I believe supports a wider range of formats than Handbrake, so it's the power user's tool of choice. But Handbrake is way more accessible for the average user, and is very high quality in its own way.

deleted 5y ago

[deleted]

merb 5y ago

ah the good old dropbox. > https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 just gold. btw. handbrake is simple to use, ffmpeg is not.

prvc 5y ago

Aside from the interface, Handbrake provides many features not implemented in ffmpeg, especially concerning extracting data from DVDs. Handbrake is also the easiest way for non-technical people to transcode videos from one format, resolution, or quality to another.

concinds 5y ago

I find ffmpeg more intuitive. Handbrake only has presets, and it pre-fills so many options for you. Why can't I just have "original" everything, just change the format? I don't want any changes except codec, but with Handbrake I don't feel confident it's not going beyond that.

MattPalmer1086 5y ago
I'm the same. I used to use handbrake, but found the presets didn't work very well. I set up custom presetsz fiddled with lots of things, and still failed to always get the right subtitles or audio or something. I've switched to ffmpeg now, with MakeMKV to do the rip. I find this works better and more reliably. It also let's me separate the ripping from the transcoding. So I can rip really fast and just queue up the transcoding.

cjensen 5y ago

Yes, and under the hood Handbrake is using the FFmpeg libraries. Handbrake's value is providing simple presets that "just work" for converting video for various uses. Want to convert video for playback on an iPhone? Handbrake has you covered.