7 ms·
There's a huge difference between insurance and buying stuff from a store -- at a store I buy things when I have a higher utility for the item than the cost to
by bsoule 15y ago
There's a huge difference between insurance and buying stuff from a store -- at a store I buy things when I have a higher utility for the item than the cost to the manufacturer to produce and sell it to me. Insurance is a zero-sum game. Actually, the article addresses that:
"The difference is quite fundamental. It’s that insurance is fundamentally
zero-sum — the only transaction is money going back and forth. When you
buy a refrigerator, say, your value for it is huge. (If refrigerators cost
$50k you’d probably suck it up and buy one — how the hell are you going to
live without a refrigerator?) So you come out way ahead when you get it for
[I haven’t actually the faintest clue what a refrigerator costs]. And
Maytag or whoever does too. Win-win! Insurance is fundamentally either
win-lose or lose-win."
- rayiner 15y agoInsurance is only zero-sum if there is no value in certainty, which is just plain false (huge amounts of money are spent managing and trading risk).
- bsoule 15y agoI think that's kind of the point of the article: When you can afford the worst case, there really isn't any value in certainty.