8 ms·
> In the case of bitcoin mining as far as I know GPU's passed the hat directly to ASIC's. I never heard that FPGA's were competitive for that. They were, befor
by blattimwind 6y ago
> In the case of bitcoin mining as far as I know GPU's passed the hat directly to ASIC's. I never heard that FPGA's were competitive for that.
They were, before the ASICs came. CPU -> GPU -> FPGA -> ASIC. A classic story of specialization.
- Taek 6y agoEhhh not really. There was some FPGA mining that happened in Bitcoin but it was always niche rather than at-scale. FPGAs are a lot better than GPUs from the perspective of energy efficiency, but the FPGAs themselves are very expensive to purchase, and are a lot more specialized than GPUs. ASICs showed up before FGPAs ever really took off, and even if ASICs hadn't showed up it's not clear that FGPAs would have been superior on a total-cost basis to GPUs except in niche circumstances.
- tgflynn 6y ago> are a lot more specialized than GPUs. What do you mean by "more specialized" ? FPGA's can implement any logic circuit whereas GPU's are optimized for highly parallel arithmetic computations. I don't understand how that makes FPGA's "more specialized". It seems like they are in fact more general.
- jkhdigital 6y agoThey are specialized in generality /s
- dooglius 6y agoFPGA designs can be more specialized than GPU kernels, because FPGAs are more general than GPUs.
- wmf 6y agoYou can't buy FPGAs at Fry's and you can't use them for gaming when you're not mining.