7 ms·

There are many things that remind people of bad things. That's not an appropriate reason to remove them.

vasili111 7y ago
Demonstrating symbol of ex "country" in which there was dictatorship, occupation, annexation and genocide is act of glorification/act of paying respect of/to that "country" and its behavior.
- niij 7y ago
  What are your thoughts on the North Korean TLD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.kp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.kp ?
- shitgoose 7y ago
  if it offends you personally, just look the other way. do not preach to others, they may have different opinion, which is just as good as yours.
rabidrat 7y ago
Can you imagine if there were a .nazi TLD? Would you think it appropriate to discontinue its use, despite its historical significance?
- yuft 7y ago
  Joke: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.ss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.ss
- deleted 7y ago
  [deleted]
- johnisgood 7y ago
  That is not the point. There are a lot of things in the world that may remind someone of something bad. Take a look at history books. Should we not keep them either because they remind people of bad things? Of course we could use a zillion other things besides "history books" or ".su", the point is the reason behind not keeping or removing them.
  - rabidrat 7y ago
    "History books" have value in aggregating and presenting information with historical context. TLDs are artifacts without context. A history book that covered the 20th century and blandly mentioned that the Soviet Union was a collection of communist states, without mentioning any other events or context, would be similarly irrelevant, and should be relegated to the trash heap. Same with the .su TLD. We should definitely keep the historical records that it existed, but there is no reason to continue its actual existence at this point.
    - Z-T-T 7y ago
      Thousands of people own .su domains (I'm not one of them, FWIW). That's the reason for its actual existence at this point.
      - gattilorenz 7y ago
        A few years ago a friend found binaries of GCC and gzip for Xenix on a .su domain: https://virtuallyfun.com/wordpress/2010/03/20/gzip-for-xenix/ https://virtuallyfun.com/wordpress/2010/03/20/gzip-for-xenix... We were looking into Xenix as retrocomputing enthusiasts and we didn't have any compiler, so that had plenty of value for us.
    - johnisgood 7y ago
      Those domains have value, too, to the owners, for one, and perhaps to its visitors. > there is no reason to continue its actual existence at this point. I might as well just reply: there is no reason to not continue. Why should we take away people's domains just because you think there is no reason to continue its actual existence? Put yourself in other people's shoes, please. Imagine if someone used this reasoning to get rid of or take away whatever you are fond of. Perhaps these domains have no value to you, which is fine, but we should not get rid of anything just because they have no value to you.
gadders 7y ago
I'm reminded of the confederate general statues in the USA.

Demonstrating symbol of ex "country" in which there was dictatorship, occupation, annexation and genocide is act of glorification/act of paying respect of/to that "country" and its behavior.

niij 7y ago
What are your thoughts on the North Korean TLD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.kp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.kp ?
shitgoose 7y ago
if it offends you personally, just look the other way. do not preach to others, they may have different opinion, which is just as good as yours.

rabidrat 7y ago

Can you imagine if there were a .nazi TLD? Would you think it appropriate to discontinue its use, despite its historical significance?

yuft 7y ago
Joke: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.ss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.ss
deleted 7y ago
[deleted]
johnisgood 7y ago
That is not the point. There are a lot of things in the world that may remind someone of something bad. Take a look at history books. Should we not keep them either because they remind people of bad things? Of course we could use a zillion other things besides "history books" or ".su", the point is the reason behind not keeping or removing them.
- rabidrat 7y ago
  "History books" have value in aggregating and presenting information with historical context. TLDs are artifacts without context. A history book that covered the 20th century and blandly mentioned that the Soviet Union was a collection of communist states, without mentioning any other events or context, would be similarly irrelevant, and should be relegated to the trash heap. Same with the .su TLD. We should definitely keep the historical records that it existed, but there is no reason to continue its actual existence at this point.
  - Z-T-T 7y ago
    Thousands of people own .su domains (I'm not one of them, FWIW). That's the reason for its actual existence at this point.
    - gattilorenz 7y ago
      A few years ago a friend found binaries of GCC and gzip for Xenix on a .su domain: https://virtuallyfun.com/wordpress/2010/03/20/gzip-for-xenix/ https://virtuallyfun.com/wordpress/2010/03/20/gzip-for-xenix... We were looking into Xenix as retrocomputing enthusiasts and we didn't have any compiler, so that had plenty of value for us.
  - johnisgood 7y ago
    Those domains have value, too, to the owners, for one, and perhaps to its visitors. > there is no reason to continue its actual existence at this point. I might as well just reply: there is no reason to not continue. Why should we take away people's domains just because you think there is no reason to continue its actual existence? Put yourself in other people's shoes, please. Imagine if someone used this reasoning to get rid of or take away whatever you are fond of. Perhaps these domains have no value to you, which is fine, but we should not get rid of anything just because they have no value to you.

gadders 7y ago

I'm reminded of the confederate general statues in the USA.