I think you're right that the members of a community give it its value, but I think you underestimate the influence of the software. Consider it like the decor

I think you're right that the members of a community give it its value, but I think you underestimate the influence of the software. Consider it like the decor of a bar - once the regular clientele are established it becomes less important, but initially people are drawn there because they feel an affinity with the look and feel. IMHO of course.