5 ms·

What benefit does the migrants/refugees bring?

by ebfe 10y ago

toomuchtodo 10y ago
The downvotes but no reply to your comment is telling. Engage in discussion people. Downvotes are for quality, not disagreement.
- ebfe 10y ago
  I've asked this question probably two dozen times to various people, in as earnest and non-confrontational a manner as I can , and the only time I've been able to receive a response that departed from "You're a racist." was when I was told by my professor to leave the room. I cannot figure out how to get an answer to this.
  - toomuchtodo 10y ago
    I apologize you keep getting downvoted.
trowawee 10y ago
What benefits do migrants bring to a country? Immigrants of some sort probably do most of the menial tasks that the vagaries of which uterus you emerged from let you avoid. They're also the doctors who treat you, your coworkers if you're in tech like most of us are, the people who cook both whatever trendy food you enjoy and whatever comfort food you enjoy. They're the people who actually believe in the fictions the West tells itself about what it is and what it wants to be. They're the people who work twice as hard as you do because they actually know the value of what you were born with and never appreciated like they did.
- omonra 10y ago
  If we strip your comment from the emotional affect, you're essentially saying that immigrants are happy to do menial jobs that the locals do not. How do countries without large immigrant (I won't even go to refugees) populations handle this? Switzerland seems to be doing fine. Japan isn't falling apart because there's nobody to cook. Most of Asia is doing fine without allowing any immigrants. So on a strict analysis of whether immigrants are beneficial to the host population, your argument isn't made.
  - trowawee 10y ago
    Did you actually look at information for either of the countries that you cited? Immigrants make up 20% of Switzerland's population. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Switzerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Switzerland). Japan's economy has been struggling for years now (http://www.wsj.com/articles/why-japans-economy-is-laboring-1459929574 http://www.wsj.com/articles/why-japans-economy-is-laboring-1...), and their population is aging at a rapid rate, compounding the economic stagnation, something immigration helps to combat (http://qz.com/173379/immigration-is-saving-the-us-from-an-aging-crisis/ http://qz.com/173379/immigration-is-saving-the-us-from-an-ag...).
    - omonra 10y ago
      1. I don't think of foreigners who live in Switzerland as 'immigrants' (despite the article calling them that). They are foreigners who are residing in the country (and most of them come from Europe anyways). It's extremely hard to obtain Swiss citizenship. 2. All the talk about Japan economy doing badly is nonsense. If you believe that narrative (which is totally understandable as that's the conventional wisdom), I strongly suggest you read this article: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/08/opinion/sunday/the-true-story-of-japans-economic-success.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/08/opinion/sunday/the-true-st... Basically many Japan watchers (ie people who live there and know the country intimately well) subscribe to this 'alternative' view.
      - trowawee 10y ago
        So your response is: 1. Some inconvenient Swiss immigrants aren't immigrants. and 2. Read this article from 2012 and ignore the last 4 years of Japanese GDP. (http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp) Care to try again?

What benefit does the migrants/refugees bring?

by ebfe 10y ago

What benefit does the migrants/refugees bring?

The downvotes but no reply to your comment is telling. Engage in discussion people. Downvotes are for quality, not disagreement.

ebfe 10y ago
I've asked this question probably two dozen times to various people, in as earnest and non-confrontational a manner as I can , and the only time I've been able to receive a response that departed from "You're a racist." was when I was told by my professor to leave the room. I cannot figure out how to get an answer to this.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago
  I apologize you keep getting downvoted.

trowawee 10y ago

What benefits do migrants bring to a country? Immigrants of some sort probably do most of the menial tasks that the vagaries of which uterus you emerged from let you avoid. They're also the doctors who treat you, your coworkers if you're in tech like most of us are, the people who cook both whatever trendy food you enjoy and whatever comfort food you enjoy. They're the people who actually believe in the fictions the West tells itself about what it is and what it wants to be. They're the people who work twice as hard as you do because they actually know the value of what you were born with and never appreciated like they did.

omonra 10y ago
If we strip your comment from the emotional affect, you're essentially saying that immigrants are happy to do menial jobs that the locals do not. How do countries without large immigrant (I won't even go to refugees) populations handle this? Switzerland seems to be doing fine. Japan isn't falling apart because there's nobody to cook. Most of Asia is doing fine without allowing any immigrants. So on a strict analysis of whether immigrants are beneficial to the host population, your argument isn't made.
- trowawee 10y ago
  Did you actually look at information for either of the countries that you cited? Immigrants make up 20% of Switzerland's population. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Switzerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Switzerland). Japan's economy has been struggling for years now (http://www.wsj.com/articles/why-japans-economy-is-laboring-1459929574 http://www.wsj.com/articles/why-japans-economy-is-laboring-1...), and their population is aging at a rapid rate, compounding the economic stagnation, something immigration helps to combat (http://qz.com/173379/immigration-is-saving-the-us-from-an-aging-crisis/ http://qz.com/173379/immigration-is-saving-the-us-from-an-ag...).
  - omonra 10y ago
    1. I don't think of foreigners who live in Switzerland as 'immigrants' (despite the article calling them that). They are foreigners who are residing in the country (and most of them come from Europe anyways). It's extremely hard to obtain Swiss citizenship. 2. All the talk about Japan economy doing badly is nonsense. If you believe that narrative (which is totally understandable as that's the conventional wisdom), I strongly suggest you read this article: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/08/opinion/sunday/the-true-story-of-japans-economic-success.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/08/opinion/sunday/the-true-st... Basically many Japan watchers (ie people who live there and know the country intimately well) subscribe to this 'alternative' view.
    - trowawee 10y ago
      So your response is: 1. Some inconvenient Swiss immigrants aren't immigrants. and 2. Read this article from 2012 and ignore the last 4 years of Japanese GDP. (http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp) Care to try again?